Oakville Newspapers

Oakville Beaver, 6 Jul 2023, p. 11

The following text may have been generated by Optical Character Recognition, with varying degrees of accuracy. Reader beware!

IB NEWS TOWN TO EXAMINE RESTRICTIONS FOR GRAPHIC ANTI-ABORTION FLYERS DAVID LEA dlea@metroland.com Oakville council has di- rected town staff to take an- other look at placing re- strictions on graphic anti- abortion flyers and public displays. Councillors voted dur- ing their Monday, June 19 meeting to have staff re-ex- back with recomm tions before the end of fall. The home delivery | of flyers showing wl claimed to be aborted te. tuses at various stages of development and public protests it display simi- lari eager have been a re- issue within the town or years. In a report to council, Jim Barry, director of mu- nicipal enforcement, noted the problem with regulat- se images is thatany restriction on the display, form or content of an advo- cacy sign or (including flyers) would generally constitute an in- fringement of the constitu- tional right to freedom of expression. That said, Barry noted such rights are subject to reasonable limits. In the report, ‘he noted some Canadian municipal- ities prohibit flyer delivery at or on a residential prop- erty ifa sign states that the owner does not wish to re- ceive flyers. He also noted a private member's bill is currently ing its way through the provincial legislature that would prevent someone mm sending a graphic im- age ofa fetus by mail unless the image is contained in an opaque envelope. The envelope would also need to display a warning about the flyer's content and clearly identify the Coun. Sean O'Meara. sender. Violators would face a fine of $100 per image. Barry said this bill has moved through its first reading; however, there is no indication if it will move beyond that. While Barry said other oon could involve re- ring flyer distributors to 5 adhere to the Canadian Code of Advertising Stan- Sean O'Meara photo dards or altering the town's sign bylaw to regulate sign size and where it could be displayed, he noted both paths present challenges for enforce: “Officers ‘would be re- uired to locate the person responsible for flyer deliv- ery," he “Often flyers are left at a home, with the deliverer unseen and many times untraceable." Dealing with sign viola- tions at protests would also prove challenging, with arry noting town enforce- ment officers do not have the authority to demand identification from the public, making it unlikely they will get the required information to issue a charge. "In addition, enforcing such a regulation would put enforcement staff in the position of confronting protesters, often in a large group, which would create a safety concern ant escalate tempers and pro- tester action," said Barry. He ultimately conclud- ed this issue may best be dealt with at the provincial level. Ward 1 Coun. Sean O'Meara disagreed, point- ing to London for a poten- tial solution. “London has actually passed a bylaw making it mandation that any litera- £ ture di Pe i may con- 2 tain explicit ‘ nformation & e sai FI "Wood: stock is also in § the process of doing the = cy same, and I believe this Au. gust, London is looking at < counteracts the Charter's right to say whatever you ... Not if you're harm- ing people.” Barry noted a similar bylaw could be considered, but again said there would be > challenges with enforce- meoyMeara a there was no certaint province would act on n this issue and argued Oakville should move ahead with legisla- tion of its own. “There is harm being done here," he said. The matter will be dis- cussed further as part of a review of the town's licens- ing bylaw in the fall. i 3 3

Powered by / Alimenté par VITA Toolkit
Privacy Policy