The following text may have been generated by Optical Character Recognition, with varying degrees of accuracy. Reader beware!

I ir'11'.'rT"7r'ry98l ' 'CP". --" ,, , _ ' re- immamount 011a, mg si '1 'er. "S-.--'.': l' . - 'Y' 'T w ' malice which he had asked them to draw ' (q _ . V " I WN was 'lrtlsttlt",Slt', the tit,',",?" e; "i,r2lrllii'? .7 C r in regard to the probable income. In 1809, tually expended was $340,817. Then in 1871 u, , 1 , the itotuai income, after part" all Do. hon. members would find that the large sum l . ' I" ', minion charges, was 82,833,5lt, which of three-qutsrtemt of amillion was mama. , 'r, I exceeded the estimate. In 1870, ed. The appro . tion for that year was $2,. '. . the receipts were 82,209,020, falling short 581,500 while trimaran" expended was $1,. I , of the estimates of that year by nearly half 816,866. In 1870 the amount unexpended '. amillion, arising from the receipts of the wai8450,f8'r, in 1869 $179,305. So that in u CrownLands Department having fallen below none ot those years had the actual expendj. 1 ' _ q the estimate. In 1871 the receipts were tore reached the sum of two millions of itu',M3,i79,rNio the estimate wtsar.?/0ti0.538, dollars. Now, his hon. friend the member I l showing a falling " from the estimate cl for Toronto had asked him to point outwith Inpwards of $300,000. In 1872 the receipts respect to what articular services the , i were $3,060,749, an excess over the estimate amounts appropriated rumined unexpended I f of $436,695. In regard to the actual receipt In all of these unexpended items the public . from woods and forests in 1871 will 18i2 works invoivedaairuU the larger share. In , ' tr,,utL'll'a discus; 2t 13.22:. te gii2ltgt1nugtltt "ma-mi: i'3i I 9 , , . l I _ 1 ', ' $216,983, while in 1872 the amount wan 18'l2 the amounts unexpended involvedanas 8073 239, a didorenoe ot 3726.256. In reg us much as $300 000, but on several other items 1 v 1 moi. sale of timber berths in 1872 less than mount. iiiriia the estimates: ha boon ) " ' 1 onevhalf of the amount realized by that sale expended. Now he would ask hon. mem _ I was brought into the semant- of that you. hm to follow him in arriving at a comparison I A large portion ot tyo nruouut from ttut between the actual position of the Province source would appear in the acooanta ot the with reference to its assets on the 31st Dec. . present your. . 1872, as compared with ngosition at "i; . tYKERTt lit h cte . , t [vied in the pre ms par. 0' I " tsl",,; "21:01.? 11211111111! 3: a; ',1,fd',1 'd'. allied them to see the improvement d . that. had taken place in the position of the ' f Hum" . . Province during the year just closed On , ' Hon. Mr. CllOOkS asid none whate vet. reference to the public accounts of 1872, hon. ') , 1 lie was sps.sakiHt M actual outs Ihto gentlemen would find that on the 31st of Do, 2 I $01111: #:9153111 'later but? 'gth 103:: cembefr, 16's. tt "ng1130 ha: invzatc: th: '- incu no . ittti37,070;i ass in on 1 'lttt was placed to the credit ot the Trev $111,112,335 31MB up td that period it had t',",' , sure! of tlie t,iitte,tt, gunfire; "r. pended in the creation of property oi value ', I menu the amounts "'0 'Iront, . d no". inIthc Province Hu..o.t.ur words, in erecting I . tet g",',tf' t: tlt, 'tttch' T, public works and buiIIdiligs which ware l th; I l tron . . i. nature o crmanen PnprovtNPl1 w lo I , that when Ih:l Blight) 1','iriT,"ii'i?re,i'ii would giveptf It', let an "ii,i,iii,iii'iii1iix I being tecer" mm to the wor can ui ings OWn Ft e ' {oust branch of the Departmeifk he Putt" Provinmr---of $1,208,662, apnt from expondi- . ' , 1 "' that less than $300,000 of the proceeds turn which disappeared " it was expanded, , at the sale was included in the amount. {which blah! 'll',. 0019331 reprosantat9F, .. , . . . _ " w ic 'sappe in a variety . Mr. J" K1!IRT. --wut is tho exact ,E tram tPet' it Af, "a? t d,' I ' , amann the re rose an we . sin o e l Ben. Mr. CROOK3 (after constitution coon"; aid of many of its ji,t'll',fafd. Bat I 1'ltdtgt 'dt, Scott) said that u found hi; in the shape of Visible g'tgr,tt,th,l, in , n in an error in eonset uenceo to P . i lo n 'ture 1807 f the way in which the information ',"hl' given . tTis; m? r'l'r1'l"l,f),xf :hich he 'Ill 'I,',','. u; - inthepublio accounts of 1571. The publ'v'i' tioned and which, being added tothe cash . I ' account, in statement l, showed the amount I T on lurid and invested, amounted to $5,019,- A' seeesved from woods and forests " $246,000 627. In other words, the Province could i The Crown Lands sales were credited with clearly claimto own property and vaiorin $403,000. INN. it appeared that these cash investments to the amount of five r tttf Ph bee _transposed, - " hon. ' srillions and upwards. Taking the lat Dee, . the communion": had pomted outta ' 1572, and looking at the position of the , him, Mt that the motftpte 3110010 Ito the P Province in that particular it wouldbe found 1 tuner figures, Of tttMtNe' It Wu irnpoeibU that the amount invested had iueruasodtoFe . r for him(Mr. Crooks) to do more than state ' 297 979 th d tails t hi h h tl , . . . ., ~1,-l. ee ewe ougenemen . to the Home the information M be I"! " l would tind by reference to the public accounts ' ' at M RYKERT Y 1 d t l I 0131: 'i'rght','ttu: 1l'lf,'l,,'il ';'h,ehl,htff" r. . - on sure o no re y ca in e mcr . , '; 'g',',',',',":':".",,'."""'""'"' 'KI,",, m "my " Mr. cahWi.oNr-rhu is cash in the} Hon. Mr. CROOKS said these were pro- 1 yank unproductive . . 1 f tably only typor :aphieal errors. Hon. Hon. Mr. CROOKS said yes l that ' members would thorough] understand that l w" on 1Potuth to tte drawn against ', I this large amount "can; by the Woods I Of course it was made productive after. i and Forests included less than a moiety of . ttlt because ho investei. it in January. 7 ti. the results of the sale. This would u In dition to the expenditure on pub to I l readily perceived when he mentioned the fact works which he had mentioned, up to Dec ' that in January, 1872, he had been enabled 31, 1571, there was an additional amount I I to add $600,000 to the amounts already in. cxgended in 1872 of $266,764, making the vested. In other words,the Treasurer in the tl lie works, "P to that you! 31.475 427. I I tirat month of this year had so much of ae- il'l's"lh" this amount, 3372.786 W" 93111 ie, 1 ; I tual cash at his credit, over and ahovtt the connection with the Railway Fund. Hon I demands made upon him from the Railw " gentle men would understand that the amount l Subsidy Fund and other demands both cur- which the hgislatnre thotutht " to appro- 1 _, rent and as against capital. that he was on. prints last session and the previous session in I I' '. shied to add that sum to the amount of aid of railways had been carried by him to a i ' the investments. f,tth2tt In 2trdnt! the Legis- I . M . RYK I, I . . l ore nvmg appropria $1,900,000 for a ' t rectified 2,21'il?gkt,f whanvss the amount speclIic purpose, h:nhad carried that tea 1 Jei'ti, CROOKS said that wouldbe 'iC,'d,"lf' ooant, 0 ed the Railway hand l given tt on gentlemen f th , l I v . Tip _ quarter and with proper 'e'.,;?,',",'-'),',',',.'"",',','.' uil,"i,fWe1,,eie,2tt2uit many under 1 I Other guide which hon. members might take g . . " to our expenditure, as with regard to our . ILyy Mr. CROOKS 'tif, thst tbe ouly way total income, might be found by an examina- m Iht the 5:11:31 "pd ',tt11 into?" {and tion of the estimates as . coo Ieeusi o as re " n res was actual expenditure in 'c',tyTif, 0:123:11? by considering that a portion of the amount 1 t and hon, members would he gratihrd il, 1 new invested, which niuhttyoalle1 upon to lineman" t or,g,'dht'..'itt' there had been . 1 ttrtet 31.11%: don the Railway Fan , was T tP amoun expen --in same e re tt - . siderable Ion momma," d'," LS,1'lli Mr. CAMERON -What I want to atrler. ttiPEte.thc11.. from tho Legislature In 1liT2 stand u, do you consider this as invested, I there was unexpended oi the amount appro: I and the interest morning from that to g i to ' pmted by the t1,et.t..i'sl"'1" upwards ot a hit swell the 1lailway Aid Fund. I . million of doLars. I ' att, Mr. gil.'"""" are not bound to I 1 I Mr. CAMERON said that to makethat a ointeretr _ atatementof any value they ought to know My CAMERON said then there was no ne- ,: ttedt',',',',', in which there was less expended ceeaity for making a separate account. , t appropriated. Hon. Mr. CROO K8 said there was not,ex- ' I Mom Mr. CROOKS said that lint of all cep.t to make a distinct fund. In connection I W, i" would girls a. 8'0" results,and would go with that, hon. gentlemen mold see that I .I I I I auto details afterwards: It hon. rttttg I $372,786 of the receipts or incoming " 'g','it2h'tt,', ttttlitter',,',," thiear Llt'lUltdt 1:11;. 9113113" t 'Te, . =1 . men on 146 n a v ce wa "7 ", I and closing at page 149 the 1U'Y iiad 81,470,556 better off on the 31st Dec. "i"2 I I the - anon-u. M "15 find that tho 'than it was on the 31st Dec. m. He thought 'c' . . . . . _ I hon. members would not say that this was ,' a, not a fair finanoial beginning for a Govern- ' _ 1,, __ -___ .