The following text may have been generated by Optical Character Recognition, with varying degrees of accuracy. Reader beware!

ree bow much Mr. Dickey had received aud the other gentlemes who bad been working for the Prison, withOU} compstition or with-- | out having given tenders. He was satisfied they woula see the bungling of the Cammis-- | sioner in this work _ He did not think the Commissioner of Pablic Works had sufficient experience to fit him to mavrage these large works, and perhaps ho bad beeu brought into these difficuities in0T0 from want of exp® ' fience than wiltul error. Ho consladed by hoping the Governint nt would bring dowa these papers 85 ansedi'y as possible. Hon. Mr. MoKELL n satd h# thought it would have been much 1m0r@ satistactory to the House if the hou. centlemn had resorved a good deal he had sad until the papers were brought down. it was uttorly imposaible for the bon geutieman, Of ABYS other meaber 07 \ the House, to discuss this subjocs intelli-- gent'y until all the documents were laid ba N C . c haka' We "CMr McKodatr] the: House, to QSUU® . * "" "lea gent'y until all the documonts werse laid ba-- to:e them; and, thereforg, he (Mr McKelar) did not deem it necessary to attiempt 60 59 into any lengthened discussion upsoa medy 0! the pornts to which the hon gensloman re-- ferred. The romarks of the hou. member had been divected chie'ly agiuiest himsel{ (Mr, McKollar) It; was quits propet that the hon, gentiomas should criticizehis action« as :Kublic man, but in doing 50 he had wan: dergd away from the asubject in hand, and had discussed not only whiat he (Me. MeKcar) -- bad done in othe PWL and what he * doing 29W,, but sleo what he was §g0)08 to do in the fuburo (Hear, hear.) The hon. gentlom®n bad ad-- verted to the subject of the Proton outrags again. Well, ho had hoped that thero Was an end of that mattsr (hexatr, hoear)--that it was preiiy well worn out. (Hear, heat ) The members of tho Committse in thi i Fiouse had stated again and again that the : report was not such a report 38 thoy agres | to, and that it was falsified by the Chaw | LEA Mr. LAUDER ealled ths ho to order, The hon. gentleman that the Chairman of the Cns sitied the report made to this the Proton outrage, &¥ _,Cye¥tr * &Bo . Hox, Mr. MonNLLUOA stated that two membe mittee had repeatedly satd was not such & report as to. _ C P\ to. MNr. LAUDER said the hon. gentleman had made a atatem=nt, and he wished it taken down. The hon, geutleman had stated that the Chairman of the Setect Commiltes had falsified the report. 2 *Cls ko« nsuind Mr. Opeat ERRTCCCCC An HON. MEMBER aitt Lauder secoaded the motiosn t.; tzsken dows. femrane o T. o t.; tzken dows. Hon. Mr. F RaSER said the words used by the Minister of Pablic Works wet? not {hose re%e&ted by the hon. m* mbar for Soath Grey, | The Minister of Puolics Works had rey. ° The NPO "Ooee was falsificd by ths { , the hon 8° \ havipg been \ Hor. Mtr I llun. 4054 . --: C3 uL ¥ 1 P I mtce~3 on ig iigast Skiys Ahest uC i «" GU »livaite _ V**6 & & hambike Mn d ly _0 T o. . w B. J both said ghat the raport DC in this House wa«* not the rep® "t 6 ayreed to. -- How diat certaid words «s hy theso gentilecaon get lnto the Uhery were 1ot in it when they a irdes a they wWoged, and i tha rapurt . C thne "®adk snvreact i. thon it 1t caaliha sc ds ce on uP hi wLat they bad agreod to beea falsitie Mr LAUCDER called fo Spoaker upon the peant bm hl Mr. paARrRDEE said ras could bo takon gontleman himself _ en made nso of by him. We ciees Li they shoald be auch worus as ®"" of Pablic Works distated, Mr, MeKELLAR reposted that 699 . of the Cowmittes, ROW in the aid that the report was mot the 10-- y agreod to; and. besides thas, O in ; man could read the evideace given * Ah.mittra and come to any ot'hez as hon gantlomas leman had statod Ovmamittes had fal« this House u2392 AR said ho h24 ors3 of that C im-- id that the roport s they hadl agrad called for the roliag of ALC. point be hadl raissd. & said ho was uo6 tistentax e remarks oi the hoo. gen-- . maie hi utatemon's, asd, emeny, A+Y, sitting bshind Mr. n that ths words pwWU CA C CC 1j iambers of the CGom-- ho report had been M. he Provinsial Secro-- tatement, and ho was they should be PU® IM® said that only bo takon downa as himsolf dictated as AR said his hon. | 0s hva, fioud ons i hao, gontle-- purt prosant* & po +t shey h «4 words pointe | ) the cregort! If the hon. takeu down, hA# 'a wonls as tue tated. rgeead t¥ 15. yory w as n# 5 i0 1+b naY ¢ nf Mc t.2 Th strict epposition to the eviden He rejoiced to know tisat that thing which the hot,. gentloman up aczinst him. Ho bad exp® would have gore juto the igh time, but tte hoo. {ontleman better of it Ho (\Mr. 'had --given -- them _ % velva rake up -- evidence a raing that eubjects, and now they to pass it over without allasion Btephonson, the member for House of Commons, who ha thore vile slanders, ho had bee viet him af carrying awsy tim not his own, an4d of perjaring warda to clear bimself of the ¢ hear.) Mr. LAUDER agaty calicd the hou. gon-- ticman vo torder, Ho inwreted that he had no right to make any charge against a gon-- teman outside of this Honte. (Laughter.) Hon. Mr. McKELL&AR repsated that ho was rejoiced that the Proton outraze was the { only thing which the hou. gentiona hal | been able t brin«z up, and he was quits wil-- | ling to discuss that question with him eithor l in the House or out of it (Caeers ) He | would now procéed to ansiwer soms of the ' accusations which the hon. gentieman bad brought agzainst him Ths charge that thel Government bad bousd thomselves to faraish / 215 prisoners t> the Caurda Car Compeoay for fourtzsen years was Ono which boe bad . heard in South Simcos, and which, as a mat-- | top of fuak wins not prue, -- He was sorry to | say, however, tha,t th'! s'.')fl"";'l""l of th';l' couatry was sach that they worl1 ba able | to provide a larger number oi convicts than | 215. When the hon gontieman ha!? maie the | atatement that the (Government were bound to | supply that number for faurteon years, be bad stated wirit was npot the fact, and had \ withbe}d, as e hak also dons in this Hoase, | the section of the coppract which had so 1 provided. The hon. member had told the :Iec\ors of South Simcoe thas the engines to be used in the Cogtral Prison would cost / wome ten thousand dollars apisce; but when ' the papers came down --and he would prefer | "o discuss this whole question with the hon | entieman thea--members would sese thas | The statement was quite incarrect, and that, isst s4 of ons costing $10,000, the two to gether would not cosh that sum. The hon gentleman had also statcd that the Govern-- ment bad boen lotting the work without tendera boing asked for Evenif whatths hon member badstated had been correct, hethought they wonld be able to show that they had a precedent for so doinz. which the member foe South Grey would not disputs. The Hon Mr. Curling when Commissioaer of Pablic Works, had iven Mr. Dickis, the contrs »tor whom the %mu member hai par> i ticularly poiuted ont, & lirgo amouat of | work, without anybody tendering for it or | hecring of it Mr. Carling had jast e--Med | BE 0P t' :n into the office, and gave him th'e KAC L.AE \ 4 d asd ¥r. Dickie into the affice, and gavo w bi°" work at $23,009, more thim all the work which be ha 1 got from this G »verament was worth. Besidey, r'tbouch he (Mr, MckKellar) h:d not adverti<<4, he hai yet recsived t3n-- dera for the work, wnich his p.cdcezssor had roi. done, Mr. LAUDER enquired refetred to as baving bsen Carlins,. Cal' Uige Hor. Mr. McKELLAR sxd it I¥v»s the -- Frovincisl Asylum. Ho know this was something new to the hbonourable gentleman, who was no doubs dis> pleased that the -- (Governmeat had done only the same thing that his o wn frieads had done. The Governmont were willing to submit every item expended or cousractsd for in connection with the Osutral Prison to *the scrutiny of the House and the coant'y, "nd to show that shey haigot the best work ior the lowest figures at which the work \cnu\dbc performed, The hou. member had t imom that whon Mr. GHO® hed cormsed 8 & 0 is fAavaram/n ind to show YDBRS °°° "*/ 8 ) y uL tho or the lowest figures at which the work | could be performefi. The hou member had %""* imom that whon Mr, Bitict h.d cermsed ; -- carry out the work, the Goverament | »hould have advertised for tapders, and re-- let the work. _ Mr. ¥liiot had {Nen behind with it m=ny months; it WA* evident that it would _ be impsesible _ for bia -- to complete _ it by the frst _ of | January, _ _O" by |;one. PEA from } the first of Jannary . and as the (Government hnad the power by the e3ntract to take is iat? \ their ow»n hands uudee such recamst in 'os, they had dona s0 In order to kesp faith with the Cavada CarComp inv, is was pacts® \ sary that 16 should ba procscded with with \ sreed, and accordinaly as mainy men as pQ3 '-' mwhlo were put upon the work. which was | now hein« carried on 23 cheiply and econo \ micaliy as it was possible that such a work | sould be conducted | The st itasmeat of the Bs 1 1(0 OM 2 Scincnichadi +A Aevinmnnint C BX T ; / it. Te (Mr. -- MoKeoliar) them -- txelva mooaths -- to> | vidence szainst him _ on | and now they wsoSts willing | e without allasion. As to Mr. the member for Kout in the mmons, who bad acurricd up uders, ho had been able to cou-- irryving awasy timber which was an4 of perjaring himselt aftar-- WBP EU Pn s ) ~A¥Fhew a evidence (Uhcor« ) & that was the ouly mtleman bad to bring 1 expectel that he he Higia frauds this tleman had thought whis work was go given by Mr. EVC IPF 10 first of 1 e -- year from } the (Government act to take is iat? \ ) ALf. | in the od up :3 cou-- h was aftar-- ("{'I.'.:;a'.v.", 14