The following text may have been generated by Optical Character Recognition, with varying degrees of accuracy. Reader beware!

pr, _ "i ' '"K ,.-' " .. a r ' li " New Bet" Lt 'SA" FYPF.' vm, . - "P. F"? ,3 - Fr, .. .. "el',?.'? Fi",'?)?:);':"?,'," J, f l . ': (Em-:7 3' Cl. $532+. _"tirC.. v/s'".-.'. '.i)',?",t?: 3'33. - 'lMtlltylri'/ ',f5slit"r'i'v'i1 ', l 3: " /r" l- T"? . 'c ', l" _ ".'" .4 . " . l : ., i J a ' f4 rg' . = It 'lE.f.e,rJr,'r",'i),", .2530": ; , ' ' f . F., I; T T O, n . " 4 . T i ' l,'. V iii, ' Mil};- by?! ',:r/"/C:',ir5'i r,', ' ' . _ ' a" '. ",3 ', _ 2. _ F .2 .f,fsjiir 41:", , il',,', ' '", I' 1 '." car11'iii3, ir: 22 'i?" __.", V I Fe 'hill " Illtiii) if,' w/fr' l-', _ , -. "'-' _ ' . """ . _ . .,- " ' - " til: i, _ i , . to have taken that interest which any Wartime!" _ hon. Irienii the lent. or a tie nonunion hail slated i . with it right sense or its own duties would have With regard to the. t'munerquestion that ho thou4ht '- ' been very glad to take. But I have some lliI'OI- the people otthia Province Would not take a n1r- - mation as to what the objeet of the Dominion troy" row View or it. it: (Mr. l'ordeei ventured to any . ernment ii in allowin that territory to remain In they would not, hut that they \vould hike it view that condition. what the 'th'i'i1 is in aggravating sviihrientiy Iren;tit tu talie, in thu whole oftlie tar. '. " the dis tire. The tlrat Minist;r disclosed .ltit viiory. IA'oilcu,e.) El's hon. friend pretended l ' _ ' ohiect-iie made public prddwuitionorltlg object that he \'i':l-l wi/mc: to tio to the country upon _ -G, did not conceal whet his purpose was. IIa these tpu'ssn'nrtvt. He would have :.n opportunity ' - told the House. and we do not tltttt the statement of doing so. iind he (Mr. Purdue) had no doubt he _ . . [ repudiated, in answering '1'lg'1tl1. that were would liwi the Verdict oi' the, people to be that made to tho turnlnt: of t 0 teturitoty Sv/w. they would not content to surrender their i'izhis . l ' its tar as they had tho DOW". t0 Mmtitolra, in the war in which his hon. friend desired they " that the oil'eet of settling the 1ouedyy; that should. "mm..." V _ i is, w, settled by that Act. the lsritv,.tinyt ol that Air. 1rr',ItriiJi1'u saidthiit the charge of mis- - i boundary "ptoput' WNW?" lryitytlttty would coin- vet'wecreu'.inr," the remarks of Mr. "lake had not i pel the present Government of Ontario to bo rezt- been disproved. Mr. Blithe did ttrrr,mt that the ihr ', tionable. (Iii-or. hour.) What did he menu by minion Government eould interfere in special q reasonable t To ,uive up our rights; he did aut cases With Ac'tiof the Provincial Legislature. even pretend to make any other tneat.tiym I now any in Cities who: t ti: We Ants xvi-re within the exclu- . we haven nelson why he take-i thiscttursye Thy sive authority o:' the Legislature. co, tttt.) He reason Why he give; tltin territory to Mur.tit.o)ra " _ thought when h JU. gentlemen opposite declared to comp-d Ontario to give up part or. he" t-i,thts. l 1 that the "trunnion Act, iii hut s when took away do not know what he Int'ltlH by hem; reasonable l Ontario's territ rl'Y. that tlu, le we . of We Goyyrtt- except tit tv-ia-tttcr-cut/l to couty.el us not jo I ment as on lion it pofiiieiiin- mid he believed him I insist "pon " tioodttry tltat,,iio said, ca/Pot.,,)"', I in moat ruse-i to Ln. honed-2 should h we. risen and , . ' insisted upon in MW ("mm m the world. I'lusl contradicted that statvtoeuttrntuestivtizrltor the 2 statement we: 2m tile that we would come to I words of tlw. llon. ll. W. "with in thu h'enate wr l WW" quickly, when WP, found that we Putt doso. ' inhaling the Aer. lie said 9-" it. is not pretended in l . Well. it is for the people or' Ontario to any I tho Act "my when: the wedern lioundnry of Ou. ' ' l whether they will yield or not. _(Chee.r:i. tori >or tlut ,._.h.,u..n Irrnurlu'rr of 11auitoh:t is any ': t l have no doubt that their- ii an impret'sion on tly, I further than to any that the eastern hounilnry of f I part of the Dominion attrhoritit'y.uhtt1iren',lrare in I Manitoba. "irail my", down to the Western " I 50m" ot the "WW '.Urtiinsu's, if tltu.rtt 3" that i boundary of Ontario." (Apylcivie.) The hon. 'irGTouir.tiatihn:rrroiuoi'onritrio aru3indittortytt. I the leader of the. Govtuattttrutl had made. "in thi" mutter. They seem to :jiippme tiittttlm he, said, a very vi )it'ni speech. threatening to take , people of Ontario xvi-readout) with legurd tothiiI torrri0ie Ioisccriin oi' the, territory in oiimtion. : ' Lupin-mime of hnviiL: their rizltts recognized. It , and the 'rm. tlro t'oiniii'mioni-r of l'utilie Works i tlu0' 'iiave, been thirst». I Venture to soy that, tlu.'.y. ! h.iil 1;.u'l thu; ifiei' sootilil t'.\;'-'i intro letu. are aroused now (App.'yuse) --:tnd that they Will _ Mr. FRANZ-ll:- .. Inrvitlsrs"--ttsi. i be asleep no more. and that they will not. t'ttst until Mr. Il till-iii! " '/il r!1:ir:;eil tho Government with t' t i ever" mlleol'in. w'd;4"r"i:""" is aurrcndered to attempting to iiiislrnd the House in Wizard to t its-4R0 ieived e new {it and our constitutional the ifr.ralitym' title-i in the dispibed terntot')'. freedom and oiir'l,". J!aeiat rizhts urehoth re. knowiux it: the Frame time that .'lll n-_'i'ee.;ient _ [snorted and _siy)ydi"vyosver. (Loud and Iona. with the Dominion GoVepttmiHtt. had been ill-Mic l continued chccriCf, whereby hoih thivnrninents agreed to eoii'iriii the I M". j'Air?ri.": said he darn-ed to makva low !y,Ity, wit!, H". "t'y..u/.i.H.'ir,? t,ei.i'i'iliiei't,y/',r. [set'tleh ' r "liili'KS with rowel to " eliztrze ot tnisropreien- " "QM-id I'ly) _".","?::'.!.').?.?. "133M ", l 13' 1,7 '3 tl'.', : _ tint that had Duo-u mode :rmin-t him it" the Pit-"W"Nun O.' "l." "Trim" {waif .";"'I|:"'"l". T." M Ii" newspaper. and reiterated by tho leader of by bniv. he 'r'lyy/y.' orie'd as T,iu;1",'i? y (.' "J?, i." le _ . this o,rrrosttiou,wirlt tiftsiirv:e to annotation Which to the (vitih' or .iii- r I'liilJG. Ant. Lib fin tut. .iiii- ' he Mir. l'orili-ei had in iiti- from a vviort of Air. posse ot, l:l','llili" i/.",i,i,r1rtidc:1iy,'iti/'/d vvittlli iile ' I Welter: uwin theiiiiiw'tiou of disttliownnce. 1xiMu'sr.1iuie'ntPny,i "s','.??.'.",',','.'.'-,':' )'311 1|} I),'.? I" I? , Mr. y 'c'.'A'l.i.l.r.lTU. 1tuad,. no chanti- ofmlsmure- 1' ".mr.t""n 'yy:lyTu..i,r/yt, liitf, 1y,1',l,':1,'jj/, i'A-lll i/rl" 1.l I Si-nautioiL NN hat I did any wnsthat the argument, {km-5"": in"? WEI"; Ht .t.i".",":("\I 'i" ii Ill/l"." I133} . I in en the lion. ;;e'itlriiiiui med in summoning his l'lie pcoo)c m /",'ryi,/,.,'.'i",1,'yiei y,., .l" i' hie, is;",'; i-.-:~~'i-:iinin ".13 on:- whieh Mr. Mlttlte put forward ' tltetti to defend to: ten} o.i.ii Hunts f! t ' " I oniv to route. viiice. end he our; wil.rryz.ty ttrueput. the full i fair. " "bull-2 .utid up uni-gin] misrepti4rmta- vcsportsiltili'y ethic ponder.) he it/ty/yy;) twin: ' ' thin! ',.r-uprctl lil tho courw- of a speech wlticlt troutliuiie' oppoqni: xvi,- 1.;i not be able to 5.311 t it. h; inn. ml in: h "lull" to nuke. and in whth he i"'"t",1P'l/,'c"."', "."'.".' H" " "H "a!.""". liii ri-i'i r: i- l to the iii-nilinv.iiii-e of the Hiversuud i Mr. r "952"" __ Uh dear. no. . l on -:in . llii'. It wouli in i-ui-olleeted he had been I Ire. .\|lu.ll'.l)l'ifll conclytedhr. srt.isityrt.hat hon. c Monti-i..- thar iiii- "oritintotttloxitutittent had no ' i m-nt'umwn ("WWW") would rcnnuniilst wherelhcy t i~;,i.i iodii.llow hills tliat wi-i-i- wsthintltu. cum- I rv,vwre-r.r,uittf;(erralciusetw-rtsspoasiuletothe peo- I p that: of tlt:" i. unluturi- to pit-:1, not, that the I ple. l livers.) i l!otititiiou Government had not tho. constitution" i i A vo.e was then taken on the amendment to. the ' right I.) meadow minnow-i which rxrrirded its i amendment promo-zed by Mr. hint-lair the previous iytrdit1;y'n. He thought he tart. the ttysettt of both I I day, wiihthAfoilowirtgreralt:- g isi li'illi the Holm- that th won his contention. i, I Yr.1.u.--.1rtsws. Apuleuy, Awrey, llgdgerow. , g' tilt-or. heart A '."".yoyy,t. l r. "lulu-'4 report Wit-i I a'lalrautyno. lluskr'rriilt', Baxter. "islrup. Blemrd. V ' i coiytl Inru, the. " "" ol e'i'lht1l'ryy. tho lytit NHL. Honilrld. I ' ll-i'n't'.i. t .latllliii'll. CliLsholm. ('rooks. , I iyyl.. i, IV Y, in". Ill o; the ','"i'""i that l.to W,"'4 l lriuvv'ue, Dr:, in . Ferris, Field. Frost-r. Freeman. f I cn . (' '"u'tthav.iy.rui.:t:..l'e.oniuryryi"w rerttrtur"ei l "snort (HctiscirsnI. (Wu-iii tHuvout, Graham. , lo. A ts' oval.» iii lie .lrlak" WiV4 ttt atriwot. to it I li.t:;ti'. liarcr tfi. ll.ii'~l;,'. lrawirvy, "ay, Hunter, ' sh. "I "I, m tit:' hi" I" "I?" "v?".. Ivtty "WI trtigvtt I frtullaw,Liviit.,sist. Lyon. "l,c':s:tui'y, )li-Kim, thin . 'tu/i. that disnliwutiue iii Provincial le_:iii- .Irlvtitiliu, Mc11rtirn. If:wlr, Miher. Mowat. Lil» , xi mid lue.hy tut: 'iovtyyv.trult'.ryl MUN". I .uutvay, Nun-n. 1hwlou. Purdue. l'l'tk. Robinson win, , ll '.hi',,1',ly"y 01' t't'y"ytcilu,lity o; his Miuis. tt'ardweii,). r'vo)ri.'ur,tit tilt-mi. Ito'rertsott (Halt-int. "In" ir. "I," t ."o'ys.'titit'rl, "Jinn". this lirOl'U'l' tiincyair. Snider. Striker. 1Vtr.tturs, Wattvrr," 'tili, III)". 'lj,) IlI::i::'l':lrlilllgi'l'(git-inlaid?"IAl'l'l'i't:lt|nrlliilrjhaxiilvl'lli't; \Veds, Vt'iddisicld, Wood, Young -:N. I anti tv:rro':niinliiy of his 1littrstors, and in N ,t,1ry.-.rll.r'siT4.. "my". Ir-.t1lTrvill,r',. Itell 'oul, l mizion't o" lii-i ati'gu'ni-iit mail-.- thi-i r,tttUt.rttt'ttt: t,py...l'",1Tfy.'/r..i.. Aim-1'"- i i"riuh,'l,yy. lr pt?rtrth. UV. .. I: iriite,'utestt? limit ii'ii t'uu:vliau Mi: . ti-i'l . my " Kvrr, 1y"T iii-nu Lon-J. harmonica " ...ill. b . H" '3 ' I M min 'i't"'.'l' ii-t- if- it ..l. l-ir, p mar or i-onti'olliu; tltctiwnacttmrttt tri'trpt't'attott or ill,",','.',.",.!,' l: f.' JI ti d I' "l I ' /.'. Trt/i. 2' FNY l l'i'iivineiul Ay't.i, the I" ns'HIIICHt'If w iiild he " l it I'il?i?; i611." 1: tat o'0ti, ltuUurtson (um ttks), l virtn ii i'i-pi-ul in the ant-tioti ol' the Ihuiish North 5 oo i). IM- --dU. _ Ami-um Ai. giving tlr. "iclunice right of lezzix- i The atrtouduteut was declare}. lost on the lotion in eerlii'u til:|'it'!'~4 to Provincial Lexi-s. I Jivisiotr. , lutiiriN." He 1 Ur, l'.ii-dei-i hail sniil that he nun-cl The third i ir:t':r;z',ih of the Ad,lreas was you. _ .wi'm Mc. "him: ll that, and " tt only in that but I On the fourth is.'tnr:yaph. tvspectirrg "AU dis. _ "V"""." other p ii'timi of hi, rem r. it 'h' on.) lie I allowance ..,' m.- , "roam.- Art. , , reiterated now that t3:itl~'?iilllitll.ill disallownneo )li'. 1ltlltt.:lv', mid he i-ronosr'i to move an " In" Dominion threrniueni would not be it amvnrlntutt. lt xvii the duty. he 1vmaNwd, of , I NINAti ofthe "who" of tho lli'itiqh North .tiiiericu _ the .'iliii'JI'P of Ju-tic" to evemine every Act , i I Ac: reform-cl to or no; section of it. tt'heeruJ pvywtl hyn minim-till Loam-mire and pisahis t I Tu" Muil mid iiiti-siipii- l to prove -and had mode j:rlur;uvtr' tl". Hi the"). T11" Act in WNW"! wa,', _ iljeot' very siron': lar.gttay,vindoirtur so 'illili the hi- (court-d. of nu "xtvaooliiuri'v Phuriir'lcr and ' _ view of Mr. Ilium- on this Hurtsiton when in power interfere-l with the vi :ht i ot proper'y. He iii ivi-l i \vuu-ontrury tothat taken Iry tlie [Wt-40m Ontario the i'ol'iiiu n," uiur-rdrnua'ut: "The: we represent t ' "'.ovluute'tt.. Mr. ulakchadtvr, takcuaeontrary ' Jo His ll mour that the Act of hut session for l "NV. I.\pphiuw.t 5o for from tttis heiin: the proteetinz: thi- puhlie interest in strenmi. rivers. ca-rits" report t.rr.llr.. Hittite was entirely in itiiil creek-i an" i-iiiilssii')' to eonqitutiimnl tulle tit'i'oi'vl Ltll't' with thiT opinion. nnd Wtt4 not tit all end in violation of rig'hN in private property aul 2 (PM?! to lilt'i'illlill iii-lion put "Wm it by thy 114;], in" ii':'iii':il ,:ai vi:('t', ind the mine haviue lie-3n dis- . lie. contended that ll Ivan' the JI til and not liiin- alt.r,w-d In the "v.vtasise of the power of disallow. _ 'g)! that had Ireuut Lin-Hy or tttisreoreritttttatimt. intro which. nu tor the It. N. A. Ae!. is \csie-iI l'httt WW?" il-'il 'IWNU'i ottly Push portions of the in the iiovi-ruur General c/ (minute. iii-tin: under ' 1 WW" und made, surh . eomments thereon its the a,lvict. of His l'1\;I-i-.li-nr~."s Ministers. who are I I would leave. the impre- "ton upon the mind of the rrsirtusi,'rlrt to tho 'i'avli uncut and people of Can. I render timid". '.""""" trad ttkeu tIto, ground that min ',i.. tho ::-*:iou oi" the tpnusiutortirutcral in the the !.h/,'rt.y.rt.ier'. Govuuururout ii'tii the right. tail}. 'f.'it'f't',.'oe" or tho alrot,einrn..',' from iuce.wnecseot' allow t rovini'::il "yrl"urr "flu-(her It was within kin-h pow-r. while We are ;uns;utred to {hix't'l't the "I'uliw'"""-v ot the Ltciqlature. to PM" tlteut und ilei'i-ti l our t' tn,tiiutiott,tl rights in regard to " Ji,'.f,1.r, tt)y.,'la'd". '. l: would, ttsk who "an the all "ulterior i'nwiar'i tl iiirl< lieiiozi 113' zlrti:ie.l , :t'ith ltr. ily;: . "dd! li:.?,.?.":,.' y.?ifty. y.,1.w.e.tT'.r1 in the El. 13.. A. Ari. .w'e do no? rrt-twd. the titw'itli- I been iiiaiii ti'dlu" :3 {Bluff} the 2i,"r!'l,f, tout-h id ls.twarv'.o oi ly Aer, ill Hivv'tiouas an invoSion of l i in," whio "Mum", "lt ' {farm ter part, ot the tltose ruins. t.\pplu:ii.-.t I ' i.irduA.Ti [ILZIitWii"ll|l::5:iii':X|(:l:i!"I'1';iI-'JPKIC'II'ILIKI:(if."r Kyle. ll.tl{Ci)l?i{F .rtp;uvly'nl'r1 that, the two 2 ti In"; ti"wy4itstpr'r. al, own" m- " il.) "I 1tarl t' uni? elm-l 'iu'r.lti'l'i uy.'ier ilisi-iiseion were the most im- 1 limit to tum un .U,///tiiiii/, li'tt'l J1'r'i'.i'/iii'/ Le,'"; porluu'. (WM. distsusimtd in min IYovinee for as Mr. mar"; [.er iii/rd/r/i/i, .mm it its l t iiiiiny yeti-ii. Hi: I'.', hear.) lliey eonwrned hound in h "In," H, PM." a y; i'/i.'iV/v, ',d'.ii'.,',n"t",,'t i the rights of the people lll this . I re l altow (h.- i.».;,- g,.,,,,._.,,'.- ii Jinx} I , Ll,",,',", a i" '3 were 'illlti the bvotl prinriple of Iroi'iiieinl I ' hum-mun" It , , I .1, ' .',-,I (Jr ti. 1,941.", _ (iii C. JI'; s'1uve,t'frir:ut..'i. it W:tq important also in that the I . T Iil"il"<l".-i if ,. "W... hal h..." //,','i7,/.',"/.',"//,fs'.' 'rrsuit oi tlt:ti (it"llUI' would. he the eftulv- inn-minim oil, tlt: txtvlinsrc,i m- 1'". hos-w") liwhiiiunt oi " iii-.---eiiezit with-ll must oiuhvrl "Men by hum; e itlonieii up ' nim- "l 1 II". l't Ill? hi'ozvlen or eoiitriii-t the rights of tit." Wheuthuy mun-1 iiiiicji'c, Numih, i/C)?')),'; i'hmiihrr. P, lvT' til") iiiiporiitnt lieezinw the . constitutional or 'Il:iii-iii~i Itrou/ut fo;-.viwd Cf. (Volt? i'r'm'ii'i" :yrlr't'ly'yy," that diyyusi:y! cyy,ciTyyl [ tlettt.nn "i this min oi' thit ll , .',.. th .\. r TINT n Cotthsucr,stiott inn-if. ll" eor-zrlUreil that the Olli) I tlu, itruefir ' o" "nun"; "Lug; .. :l'iii""li"iil l to . Iogiry.l l'tlilt'illi'illl oi hon. s:enth-nn-n tip-goalie was I . tin t in tht, I? , s" I, hr, trim" th,. iton '//Cl.i'd,'i".al I to ail-mun ""ir/l.s' blow u' t'ou.ft'dtr1ttiltty , ll'? "'th'. becriiriir) ' V h l ..i| ""orttlr'lv and mllt 2.2"" u!ly If ' riotiit nil sutnr.isei at the rN-ill ot the denote: to i rip-.1 I]... I. L, '_ .. Hm. in," In..." "H l . _ 'r.'.. Ci SP? the two s:tu'itt vayti.tstirau.u'.n'.rliiter!yyt/l..t iiiiil I him. Uni in". .f'l.lit,'.ll 'it tin-Mun. t ii",fa",ti', iihiirplyon tit-u'nttosCutus. Knourmvztlteltislorii , entice the t 'i' in tliii Iii-v: ' r'..l,"- Iii": l (if the two p-irHi-s, Ite Would have ili'i'll surpri'rd ,. to lint in t», t Mir;- u ttlt td,'."ir,. iii-rt , "u. I ilt'l n'iy otlie.' result tin-died. it had been ever thew. t no J,"I' 'ct.' tr'!" iv; 14, 1', 1;, "t , I}, ( l l I thin wirou the preininitivm oi the people were . tt:rl the d all Ct i-- " m. :4..." ' "i/ii, ward 1tttdetl,,vutiilou, I',uyiaurthi'last few . ciystlu'y .. .. 'tit '.lrll. Ile,' I found thosts on his ".illtt ot' the llortse. true to their ' , . , , I . ' . ' 3