fi------mq MHouse U onl e us nani On Income T s ! * me e ! remier He & i burn w his in the epburn won y s claim, in Ontario Legislat yesterday ment had cited that the G & of the entire A ure the back-- tional!l and ;:l(:eved them 'of :(\i/ern- H 1 s' '. w r:ao(:lon declaring tha'te?:'blypfor his fi':::'semem 1a;0 (r-z:],': l:pealedut(;:e waseo{f:fififii'-'d that the Premi C'O\'ern & t over the mill return i ad made & id £ 0 Pducauon 6/ et in re-- | ment in n Federal erp 0 the municl a one-- said, '"the tim -- . *T think}" [tax: the field of income m"n:':rtmlmtxa Ee illto:t;:lga}:)'wih f(r(r))vlnr'e shotflt;s t?:;?d"e Whe;\ tll:: | Di\isio 'n"nd. xpa.'-ers nn . P e * er (\ent 0[ t over &t le [aome on on C ns Ne fhel d fia""°'e:fli:lorr~1:h% municipal® politi-- Fig qwie Back to" the. ;ducath:'s't' P s > current A 8 ng a . Croll. * ;. _ his own ridin e position H vote, in w session for 5o round the P s But on go-- claimed i g and city, M of ~% oubt a f Psult was i U('lanq ncy of m C ind jig read." sor w0uld hav ar th.t Wind }Lonser\-a"w: OS members of n The to play the unicipal poli-- taxes to e to raise addi & pposition joi the hey were, old shell 7| t th meet its relief bi tional iprr'."ent spea ion joined 7 p in & he clai game. e Federal o ef bill, d [ True, kers in support of the to keep the lax T; Pudgers sround. Ts mo o ramig. _ onlR secision i rup. 'ho support w old level e tax rate dov l around, {.p pointed out th n certain was conditi ins and assu n io ths: | & biHl befo at the cit secured hisph:isps' but the P;Llr';l'iml "'{"t'@r.;t'lllo{ placing 1'1}1\: credit for it ""l'inanvin:;e t;{ House dealingy\\l'il:g : | mous House v m--that of a & i sonment" """_ gra credit on the! ***4"* every ons said he want | is desi se vote on a ma lll.m.m- nment. nbed by the G x its wo y one the city w ed to | ture :'""d to be an im tter which Queried Abo f 10Y® | | of th"!'d about refinancin oud keep flLthe Row (l}ntario's pregg?,';t'm fea| Hon. T ut Windsor Uph ldlddltional load g in spite rell Commission ation to: Whip, Int A. Kidd m . Upholds Provin f . Croll Reo C210 § Winio: 'nu-rrupt»dI & Conservativ Hist ovincial Powers. | 'hy, w Mr. C ive story did n i| Th pens Debate | why, when he w . Croll to ask the c ot altogeth | | e debate ( | sor, the ci was Mayor of Wind-- .' ontention that "& stt support | ':i';;:\r::;i on Fri::v "':.;' motion, ad-- mlfi"cip'llni';v(;)oy::o:'d only ${2 %n?r; d;afiligfio(';:rtl:,ment" \EVasa (?\t:o;g. cen-- || David A. Croll (Lib., W reopentd by I wan in w oA ax. f Nort he framers of the Britich | mer Ministe fo., Windsor), for-- | Wihd replied that Wi rth America Act, F of the British nicipal Affai elfare and M Windsor i d position ge inister of Welfa . Eric Cross the Provin rs, who empha IU-- ) just n imposed th ; that if We have re, declared * ce by A sized that / moved to W e lax, pe that e certain * _ cure additional m ecessite muast se., x' i Valkervill ople : act and ~ft powers und | | l * st se-- * er C or . & | su his R er \ | lief grants tol L':nd§ to bolster re-- tax was n:t the municipal i:(:)nd- 'thfr';me- as long as itf'!!:'llament w ; :ilcula;ly since Fg:":'('lr;alities, par-- :':dod_ +Wls' did('?'l:N'tpd. "But !;'1: 'thdgell;ms set for thes:xys within | ons ave h(' ra appro £ ® 'hin e next h@(' [ . * | "~ owc!.s." h' h erciSQ o' | "At the oulset shorn by O prist done hen that should ha thing, |_ '"The Ro > said. | 4 outset i n ttawa. here, A hav well Co n ack | || that neither o. Henbarh Nor mems vears ago we amain roronts arca \ not be expected to soive should | :';rs of his Gov}r'ne,',',b"r h nor mem--, *"§%, *J pay > amalgamated and NOW |Fur blems. 1t will ho.::,)lve all" o. he Federal A t .Pnt question '; Mr. Kldd w | in finding n_; ver, be use-- || right t imimistration's fegal | x then poi |ascertains many facts. $| o collect i ion's legal indsor ha inted out e the risin if, it §| _ The only O ncome tax cent rel} d applied 1 tha, --ernment in sing costs of | 1} i 3 itd * * let j or 1 relati gov-- § | 11"1 the adjOUrnl:I:lO;let:,on voice raised ince and "'::.\g@n]-g from 'h:mprger «';;Y;;T Income, it 0'3"1]0 hthe Govern:| . G'o{\:' Frost, Victoriam:";"as that of ;&;'flrfid that h,o{";';"'"- Mr. Groii | Say °]d a great deal." ave accom--. 5 ernment in 5.L. 'ho told the per (\pn'. 6 nppo_gpd ivi ~may® nvasion Ad i its position w critical mood that i . relief on giving l T s mitted. eli r th t wo the |_ The ri | ::gl' l;, h g'rlil:l'bfom:l}fh Strong:'t' ?'if',""- Th:lgo:;:?r hdo"'" Pi';'op'::': ip"SP inccg)}r:eo:a:::'e Provinces to im | § ished the c clection. l it way M 100 Der cer id Pinally| Lennfeanna't s was established | cut the aut amusement tax and it was on per cent relie ally |Confederati as 1866, a ve ished : g: action, rt\%mgl"t:ilrennc]license fe?ed opfiflsed the rr:;:;:,rnd tnat hef' l?:d 1A"d "'h:\"?g'e Ng' C"OSS) c::,t:;fi(:!'; 't; asure an e »d, was in &4 4 r. Cro" * !DOSed s OminiOn A +1 i rr:);:'e; and :'gg'ifi:;'onthor rinancitfi :l;'l':'inistrati;'h(-'a}lul:g :2:' the Henry | White md";fflflf( 'da"- Sirfl':isrt\o',),:z | ch we # at did ) money d spent consi " |vasio 4 ed it was " Awea \ match weh With a" demand for a the Hepb ol Rimpaiies (Rioeni ooo PAOI T | 0 ; justifyv thi " T ad | --| Calls for lludjustmeme feeee e Hepburn regime ad'::;t.e;v Noi e 5hc.-nnp('es-<ity." I\Zrlf}Crt::)s as "a pub--, He emphasi nt. as--y a pay-- | ow are the P oss said. | | phasized s--you--go plan £ functio rovinces goi | 3?dth.e riight to G;h:;':i}::bfm"i"" Sha' began to'g.entda' 'l'i'ltztl's "i'h'" the Ib"eaksn(_:c:'".','::..F;'{deral Govgg:\r:..;? ncome e share e bra e tight." caulay i en on. L & be, he said, eithetra: There should Premier ;'{:;':) suggestions -- that | Thg ,,l?f'er-lemed. eopold Ma-- the taxes or a readj\::::j"'-"mem in ,l[,)u.Pll'Ssiq of Qu':{,':c ':"d Premier | "U""" it 1::',,0" the Dominion Tre | ) ern responsibiliti ent in Gov-- ) Pliny q the Rowell fere "ganging Ifirst rights i rovinces were gr i fion. sibilities borne b silly talk." H ell Commission a not be vi s in income tax granted | +ep y taxa. Gut f e claimed i § ) | viewed with es, should| The Domini : y of the Pr t was the .answer alarm,. M ' minio , inte emier to | % ed, as aft ; Mr-- Cross | erigih amoun PSE o all reliet "or interests of the citizens protect the \he was laken" beex about Snesame amounts ho r relief "I * i J s taken awav." hne sgme' ::g* taxes shou,::e:,"'ed from i?\l.- talk ?,? 2':?'0 that in spite of all th i"?' suggest 1},';:"'0 HC'Went on | mugp'nsa!ion to the P returned in Premier "-igi"' up." he said --,he | & oulder a larger ehm"'o could | M' bear the load," he said. -- that | °o presen." persist in his éffone Neving" and 'other osts of social' p r. Frost Brgu' e said. people t the problems of & | lieving the munic osts, thus re-- rovinces, in the qed' too that the [ W'th ":J'MII these voices grow w his | ful sources of re("fluahtues. if right-- ;'bl:";eConleder"-ig:'Nlnl'hat brought | ., Th® Plrrof-?,:fi"',,""""-'m-" weary ' tax) were return\egn:': l(t'he income _ sense of . must have a, O"/V® e, he held, is bei f national sens responsibilit & | Griven to action by . is being oommatstsils f sense a y in the| °5 v the municipali im emariront on | fnceroa - $ about ni woul back to -- r money is | strong Provinces :'d ue woel ang | should ohth, municipalities p:;sed | ";" Government. nd one weak Fed-- munivipali';ie"m"'""" placed whe fror: ::\-Ot'ltpd strongly concerned." s so far as taxation ;;2 S onections 15 carecnig Mb dirieg oc This, claimed M | j"riSdi'g?:n'o collection 'l'l""odr:w tax | :ased in relation tro ?;)'::I. ;hould be | j r nder one eneral iti r debt equitable re with provis conditions of s and 8 turns to t sion fop| Structures. Last : their financial fgone n " m | Doh dn ho centimge unici j * an it di 4 re on relief tied in t.}?:lr;nrt;'t;"'sls were strongly fmphasizg:id .::ine'::f'atlon. ande"}:: tax, in Mr. Cro on affecting inco y | national problem. at relief was a costs w lI's opinion me -- Look upon the muniel properiy "cl ellel | 'aoa ter Beaaite, ni he municipali y charges 'I think th 4 cipality i palities. Ea the motion F tou gvirit of the resolution as they i P rocineis? °C n rurioipalitisy any the C costs w urdens / roll. *"Th nt," said r:;f,:"'- he said,""e already in **** aolio,,'- Dominion is b0unth'; are no * -- solutio more rea i Aenaiies auel f ablens sign a 1 . s try rhgr with an eye{:'flt to put out }i. ?". roppfl'.' "id ie canlden yerrs ige the Provin a rs f % taspaser," 'and "In support of e _ OOOcvvinrnrnnnrreer .cc