taking 'notes; 'they were not tlemen opposite Rtoronta, He clerk Taylor; he was be: '| punished, not kept in office at increds- great director of 'He 'was all that goad part. Thi record. He was that "be wos on the , But no Was nev- bare, was | Ar eA ,» and why not ? his charge he pl his honor the provincial secretary's. Se . Tarte done, and the accused went out on his case. On the Gamey arge there was a dotble verdict ; the accused had rovéd his case and the defence disproved it afresh. But if it bad been a proven case, a minister would have been driven out ; 'were gol atives to take no chanc- 'es? re was mo parliament, eitieh or foréign, where person who fai good high ch did not. BD re Se y Gamey } consigned the provinci- tary. (Applause). been' spoken of the Ro- affidavits. No one but the the 'house claimed | that ly excluded 'from i ' ing. The printed re- cords ' show, and he read the words, on | that 8B. H. Blake, senior Gamey toun- pi short- reporters; they did not and pould not tdke notes, 'and so 'swore at the investigation. What was the motive in that false evidence ? (Hear, hear.) FERS, hy i {one of the most highly circulated, an Ss management arg Was now no longer even a suspicion. While the limit was sold too low at it was sold too dearly to the Charltons. But, low as was the govern- ment price, it was fifty times greater than 'the conservatives sold limits for 85 per square mile, The tu quoque ment was not always conclusive, it disclosed the insincerity | of regarding public would not defend the ing properly as was the case under im proprieties during conservative rade at Ottawa. (Applause.) A Necessary Defence. It was a taunt across the floor that the judges had to be defended. Yes, 1, had declared that all the evidence that ought to have gone in had been received to his = perfect satisfaction. Not one of the other side believed in these affidavits, even a little bit, and now to use a borrowed rase, they allowed Mr. Blake to stand them up in a corner with their faces to the wall. Indeed more evidence was heard than the rules 'of éourt warranted. Honored The Judges. It was openly charged that {he judg es" deliverance was dishonest. Now the x by the case in the hands of the commis. sioners with. confidence, for they were men, honored ' for . ability and high standing, men he had known all his life, and wi acquaintance he pri- vileged. . Yet these chief justices whom their counsel lauded were called "high muek-a-mucks," and treated with continuous offence, the 'of ition ap- plawding vociferously. Ir; Graham then read an article froni the 'Canada Presbyterian, . declaring * the verdict worthy of complete aceeptance, be- cause of the character of the tribunal, but as the other 'side were not all at home on theology he would take them, tq favorite secular paths. 'Then he read from the Star, the most 'unreas- onable of conservative journals article declaring 'Mr. Whitney's ar. raignment. of the judges a great in- sult and a party blunder in which no section of Ontario would follow him. (Hear, hear). Gamey Not Believed. Taking up' the' trial record, Mr. Gra- ham declared that the unreliability of Gamey could readily be proven upon own statements. 6 'gentlemen opposite indeed. declared that his story was'onlly mainly true. They did not believe he got. money in the way he alleged, or that Frank Sullivan re- ¢eived a cent. The 'member for Centre Bruce declares that a, chain is no str than its weakest link, there- fore ought to drop "whole chain, The accuser had every oppor- tunity to make it strong. He had full leisure and much help, to weave his own details. He bad no excuse then of forgetting as at the hearing, The whole foundation rested on de- tails, and now these are admitted to be faulty. The 'opposition could not,' and the country would not, swallow however, the Manitoulin plotter rushes to the bapk and declares "Eureka, I ve found it, in my glove." Then he, put in a crumpled slip with the ori- ginal figurds but it was a second for- gery, not having correct initials of , no hole thro which the ori: ¢ folio number, our, retreated towards sstings are clean and extra heavy, while the steel used in the dome is of the finest quality and is. specially made for the |, * Sunshine " furnace. SOE ont Every detailed feature in, the "Sunshine" has its purpose, and all combine to produce the most hest from the fuel consumed and distribute it without ' : Burns Coal or Buffalo--leaves, slip and 'accuser, all. {4 rone ! No his counsel dropped the case, and only résnmed it at the government suggestion in the interest of the people; but not to act for [3 Gamey, even though he returned under the influences of Mr. Hanna. Why was he not put in the box ? (Mr. Whitney ~Why was he not put in jail?) If he was not afraid of jail why did he clear 'out ? Before the commission he [| offered no denial or statement regard ing slip or leaves, though given the opportunity. Queer State Of Things. The Manitoulin member declares that Frank Sullivan lent him $1,200 | on an: do 0. U, although the latter was #0 poor his father had to pay his house remy. This was months he. | fore $1,000 was paid, as alleged. Yet Gamey alleges he received half of the $1,000 from Sullivan, though he owed Sullivan * $1,200, lieve that ? Why did he not mention cash transactions to Moliregor ? No wonder the opposition believed the story in part only. - Fi | his care in working up a plot, Gamey had not kept a 'copy of any letter of his, even the bogus one he made his son sign. This was very suspicious. Then he has used the al leged $1,500 bribe money, for which he gave no value, and whith is real ly stolen goods. AN he retwmed, or intended to, was $500. When the mplied hy the Thenbe = i y the membor for Algoma. Gamey has the 'money yet. The op- ition "declare they know where 4 ask for a reward of '$10,000 to discover it. "The member for Algoma is deeply interested; he 'wants that $1,500 back. All the while we are beig akk to condemn' high court jmiges their accuser is improperly do: §i ing business wi perly obtained. Gamey avows that he would have told about the $1,200 if asked. But he overlooked besides that $900 de. posit 'and $250 at Gore Bay, all of the same Kind of money--the $900 and 3,300 being from the same block. iven in paying over on compulsion, Bho mobos for Algoma's $1,500 he tried a by offei a cheque pay: able to his own Ee and ' really valueless to the court or any one else, For his 'acts the jurlges could not but i - give verdict for de' $1,500 as impro- No Impeachment Found. The prosecution had traced every avenue of government. moneys © aml failed to extract even a suspicion. Yet it Was easy to accomplish if the guilt was there. But there 'was an other avenue. Suppose comservative subscriptions in small sums had beén exch for large suis at 'the On- janis ank, there would be no trace Gamey kept a diary, vet vould not tell dates or would not for fear' of contradiction. This 'was a very strange symptom and added greatly to the Jack of erédence. More singu- lar still was the alleged 'drawing up of a plete agreement "with | the Sudliv, for bargain' and sale at $5,-« 000, | i its early destruction, thoughefitViwas the positive evidence Game desired in his plot. With that Hocumedt courts would have 'an edsy time, his case would be clear be fore: the howse. It was the only in- oriminating document he held, and' it Was evidenve ho sought, vet he de. libecatoly destroyed it, amd kept no Could anyone _be- | it" the 81,500 was | = Please day, : July 8th. yis till youget your feet. fitked to a pair 'of our MEN'S OXFORDS. Enough styles and sizes to suit everybody. We'll see that you're properly fitted, too. : ; pr ------ -- | SUMMER VISIT OF 1908 PROF. DORENWEND, Bait. Goods -Artist, He will be at a British: American Hotel ji al y %4 Re WED! duly With 3 e kind RAE it a TD of Ladies oo and Sho ioe 's Wigs, Tou- or Bwliches oF all oul aa a a: A eo and shade, ' ra His Art Styles kn, d bo i A rune A and | worn © Be sure to visit his Show Rooms at! the hotel and see his new designs. 5» demonstrate' * He will, treé of charge, . by: fitting you 'what is the most suit- able and becoming to you, as nd . +'Their use adds Health, Comlort and 'Younger Appearance. Gentlemen Who Are Bald should investigate and bee hiss Featherweight Tcu- pees and Wigs worn on' over '55; heads. remember day 'and date; Kingston, British American Hotél, Wednes- i Wholesale Liquor Dealer Removed: #0. 208 Prinosss Street. (A. R. Martin's 61d pfand). Kingston Bottling Works Manufacturer of Ginger Als, Plain Sods, Direk Bes, Tdmon Sour and Orange Phosphate. All kinds of wines kept in stock, "Phone orders promptly attended to. "Phote. 313. ; Agent for Copsland's Celebrated Al, Porter and Lager; also Fisher's Ales and Porter. Kag Ales in stock. SUPPLIES Wovyen' Wire Camp Cots with roll up mattrasses to fit, Folding Canvass Cots, Folding Reclining Chairs, Folding Tent 'Tables, "also Mirrors and Pillows, etc. JAMES REID, 254-256 Princess Street. AMBULANCE w7. Our Coal 18 AS Blan As Fiough | It Were Washed and Brushed. ford FX COAL THAT SUITS. "Woot of Queen St.--'Phone 9. Mr. Gamey was an insurance work- [Photograph of it, mor even a copy. hey I - because they had been grossly attack at | Lotild anything be queerer ?' Amd he od for party reasons. He had no] er. In that pursuit he had a t qualms in Sanding up for their in. | training on dhe importance of dates, Sovbtoted 3 fnfore he got a dollar, 'Jlearity, especially against 'the criti. | Yet in 'véaving a web that was to ae ot by Whey the only excuse for "J dism of a member of parliament whose | Make 'him a greater man than all Be _ ne ig to "extract money, dence was by them un. [other leaders "and parties for thirty [He put himself. out in' the cold with- if worthy of belief. It was the legisla. | Yeors, by pringing down the liberal out document of mosey. Was if 80} tures right, and their duty, to criti | goverment, in this great climax of | opadible ? : aoa Sk en hut. to dall the judges' actions | Hie, he ignores dates, don't know'| Mr. Graham here detailed thirteen false and it, is not criticism, but | When he wold "his "honor, as alleged. Whatate and distinct pointy upon e iad, unadulterar | NO wonder" the opposition did not be- dicted bya ovidence was contra: Hogi, Lotus aad a: | aheat. conshirney, senior ing wp a dicted by. ob or more witne depos: sible evidence, yet could £3 ty who Sind 5% Ilge or Jury would role 3 is was o, e no documents and his turned and he looked out of the win- | verbal versions were disproved, ¥ dow. Did any sane man credit such | &l to his ' was the reputation of Bvery | 80 ahsurd theory? Yes, detai less witnesses. for the defence, Very weak, as the opposi The j brought in the only ver- ted. Then the provine ary | diet open lo men bearing weight of Fas not such an idiot as to show a | their high mission, True to their bribed man the denomination of bills | leader, one of the best men who ever 'and thet hand them over through | led in "this of an Ere) Wwe Stier iden. The proposition was an ot Joi La 2 ily : opposil claimed The Destr. Evid Ys § that the chief justices had acted as] gy. abouts on i: from the 4 commingionere 'will not As 'ulges, and] Croesin factory cash - and fire. not, therefore 'as highly Privileg- | rageonsly las tor the hands of harris: {lin. | Ech rh vd LR th wl ga Y 4, : Ra a by % was politics. first, motality | hime The book To Lo Which son The Hest Linimedf. . ; long' as they | con of the ; gu LES : Fat othe id 3 >" I'the » Balm$$8.734, 85, must go up before that of the | thro down: The poiiaifners wor i ause they were jutiges. p 3 | ! x for Duck and "Pique Street to judge of me- a 3 ade a "8 [open 'and wis oily x , 50, $3 cach. : further declat- ; denied absiragt- |HeV6d. "IN fact it is' Whe beet fami 3 S060 0000¢ PEA GOAL Makes an excellent fuel for summer. . $6 per ton. Ready-to-Wear Garments Sales in the above lines gre greatly on the increase here. Jf you want a Skirt, Waist, Wrapper or Jacket in'a hurry, we fancy we can suit you. Print, Wrappers, 60c., 75 X $1.50, $2 each. + Tog, 81; 81.95, ¢ © HARDWOOD, SOFTWOOD, KINDEING. $ 1 = SPOOL GOOLE Come Summer Jackets in Cloth and' Silk, $5 to $11.50 each. \ Serviceable Print Waists, 89¢. and 50! . § ¥ atl : . Cravenetie Waterproof Coats snd Ul- ea luin Chambray 'Waists, $1, $1.50, $3 | sters, $5 to $17.00 each. White Lawn Waists, 69, 75 5 100 Sample Di #1, $1.50, $2 each f¢. 85. irom $8 to $10 Black Sateen Waists $75, $1, $1.25 ET a Phe y . The wh 9, 31.25. 1 3B Very 8 Skirts, Un a ech lined ren Tite, 55 and $3 Sars Waists, Gilt Edge each. + " i $4, eache. 5 5 : nad: h is. in , all lined: eles at $1.50 # ross, Skirts; no-go alike, Hoy c 1 - . 9 \ for it by gettine oT RTA our Electric Fass 'We sell or rent them. sizes, all prices. : Y,