cle gazette m a c i i r ntfcr i 1 1 i iiv saturday jri tvitita i miev wmjj ohron jj items- 1 aajatfj fat hfia mtu 1111111 it rill lri it r mio k mm it 4 o4 i i v wfdnctoav lifltihrii aei the ewntrutt tt mfulurr tr strtiik i40ih4ia irtna need w towtinm thramuutitf ktautac iiibmiiij unclfc cunr rove riscr john rn mm tii x rrfrf emrnjiac4uriij si am 4tt w ftrl iarrlson f mj id rad irtlfjs m tiaonteiiiiia kj iwlvwr 3 4jt fcfl and iw earh hibftuc f i lr id per line first insertion end id eubavnucnl insertion 1 1 1 ci j tiilliuul m p in j l jliimatitcrf mtrthrntfijt from tin nvhtopmir whc a irrrfiutor ctmftatncrt infer intatiou letter phm rfimnii- nrrnar cfyromde odette niitnvkik a uaskttjg slattnery warohoune lhil llckbluu mild 1 i r 1 where it kept pmiimu hhd an j m in rpt t onatemly un 1 in 1 imu- v- tf and kingston commercial advertiser lfc hugo pfec popou scd utroqcto vol xxv j kingston canada wkdxesdlv january io 18 14 fxo 56 mfl blxhanans second letter toilt editor of the frrilliti fnlnilil toronto 7ih drccmbtr tfi3 tvlj tafrf mr hmekv leticr pg cd in the wu cumm of yeaiday i k hip y a aurpneed 10 b able in ihr pcem ip preiae thai gentleman aiodcraiion of in ad croj one who- hat wilncmd hi ji f mol observe the narked dflffflhbvlwfet the lone and manner 0 j pre n elk md hiv farmer writing and mhical cottjuel the language it however secondary coneid- vraiion tndit ibr puwic l u m0dr atoh ftaltuji i i 0 v j ttliht phinrublirjh lh cownr if were tojudfcbj mr hcw othmtmr iftt rcmk 0 h or ftlr itm m hwflcic 1 cj x s wppw0 lhm mrdnarrrfikff he crunjc the ggr d i uy chaiaetcr n hrh a 1 im r u t ci mih or public toil ibc tubllt wc wfl wy thrti lout at otnl t nut howrtf lkir rmarl hui piwam talc rtlun tothrralonj aaer an r- f i jan tn evhml i hie chand m opinion ef mr bnfjwif ffclj po mn to br cfttriatcd wiih ibr po nrf od atroit of ikc tw poliilcfcl tuttfj hte in tin av cuctl ibe mm at inj alf y kir been but i now feci mtttfiftl ht thcu can be rarrit inrocjfrff taonr nd belief by m wlhi witu liraa t likrril n htr fi l j i iid mif irr nisonl j rfuw iifdfi- intoirieaflrffffri at 8rmk tubject 4f ean therefore iplfeahrte lb 2rrawl pacticl anoued if kbtetliiffi feur prmp l woyu uit enj- 114 inio ihrf lrlrf 0 exfctita itij v r t 1 kaee n ihe frertel oblctont to mr bu- wfiit mjrr4enjtfro4 rf sir cwut mrtnlfci iraltuw rtwtitt 0vtfj hitcantl tfwt bin at 1 ini w l wimii to lf r -t- rrrfy tbriradvir on eriy nd f kb ctotiil lift rnrnt ibklvll in whon hit ex- tclkncr cn repotc entire conndcmec mrciher objnoti io m bamia a part rn j i ohatt o on o rx44tn by and bjc limtfrttvitftm lttl tunhf rtiaiiueattnn bul lei of cam htnji of jjrr vj writing papers sij- r limll r 5t at c fi rf ihc ittioj1iiie aii ink books school books fcc la illittnraache rarrirdon allhrtbovr h llmnn a jhjmfiflf kiiim hcuplt iiln futlopcriiori y which mmnk boob c q r ruled to ny r and in i ylt itirrliottononr- 7xe t4fiti6iii4lmm prist1so qmck book htshkh y and statioseh y warehouse in thn etlcttttkn- gnt if a drridtd iuptnqrittf in feint if 6ttwn datfon and dftpfitrk chiorticte it gazette uffitc kington canada rrofirn thoum lhattho y i- gotrrnmeat ilklo ptrtiea who by thi o eooduc ii n l tuoporier people ai lnoo m n lft lpb b uhrd under the britiah conniuuon i u nol f n eal ea- l v htka in order to p that ajrdyorf hey are jtn- h the power and pa- tilth colony andhfa patrtotban p will or tor b time to joae the portion of hit t nhieh were me baldwin iia ifkrlueneed front proprr roen tl bo entruiied mnfl of the urt in a if my rj j rgitrtl r s nade bit lord tailp iflif for a aweejt of place and power bee pwifmlleikad eiowa and fniee i eonioeftd i frit l beua h of ny own eharaeter with ibe rhipr ih4l i iei lua of all conaoveice in ble baldwin pariy ehteier j mtj b allowed lo qwote lli rasnly tebn r m ala general jatoa awtlh rbuvii ma jnr donmna tar of hit ovpfnri ifxoiutent in ihoojeaof public otiitwi l hnet man major ad i ail afeaed to ebne oy opinion for no nan need to fear iheliare of hfeontittenry wtiotf riea ran oi be iinp oeid whoar of- feueca bi born 0ly oatntt facttont and parliea aiidnolajjainat the tanof hii cowiry or the fotin- dation of society all that i can poibl b blamed tnr ft ihal tt lreneica of my octottoi lo repniblc ttuit ntnrnt hf hateud naoioeooprmo ith lad n or bad tubiccmplo aeepuh bl mhnrda would aorrlybea joodeod lixor fvffwerwaiil i orra lurey jrrortfnviof the truly briiih r or hut papulation to tthom il it my kiyhri ntfse d ftoy w nitioa fttfy coenteeuh are afttayl in adune th ul- armabofliuriy in lb a eatr coiintremrn ne seollh ettfer hare wufced lo ere ht utiol rn ihe nrhl ij in d inrioenuch rmhrt than iuq ijuwi ftr tiff ft1 pic of llifie natkr enriey i but wr fwver tor a r rz- mil 0jr f lo tv dinger ikat ihr hj bm itnwitlioltr hid w sw s iioasct aihi that vc mum jimmlay tfijm- fcylto fall 110 chaejbdii aa ti hm been lo fir loetl ami imii seotehr u a mailer 01 ik- moil tuttout coiicrrj lri ii omlin k- onrt aw iaenaeinr roeha fbljel pi nr htb cb biyon r hmlo idd v aitl onit or ltmpn and u tti d44- ihu c nhil d iultt ifr hido ahdo ttw bl iioktinlttnw irroottph if iieuliiiooartt rvpm4wii okioif jawni loilrace u pi 5f fa irimwifav ma fltfc if i to f el tfce cmlvtr ahrnee otall yt total aniwrtjilir in fei l f mr raufe to derlare any irifanwtbti of mr hila- trfl prae tie at talenta and to utm maftl i bflt llirreareftw fae an fit for tin iph i f ortrtfiror of the inspector general l it itfo fir 10 adii ki in mr namnn htatawi or a0fe pmprrirfrhbf uficm fa il it important to difiiiuili ltji fmm l polite acta i canwff here wat litili titikh tit fooar frot dfl lajaaffd qanrtt oitd be acceptable 10 ihe public mind vf ufvr canada mr daldam iiwies h w md tllawom tin jtt tht trw iner mcmfo sr- laliee aei oe rrm the tafeiy of a pjrtirnr rinei yle iiinld in a pirtnvr ntelue doe 0t c- oarili fam any uarinteo to th eoloaiiaia of itaa lafol ofdialotol rmblic oe national prineipl of the ipfmtlavj oihrnir mr lioum bf nllraj nn ron- trtre to ihr iu of ottr arniea to tvt tjk tpvaltv eero mrma ac rtww yi frj io nonr rf the hn danirl wrbtlfr or an mhr r k jttfkjm afrma hhaiit i miskl itoe from iho viturd stct fo hr purpose t adipl th mi chjibcy rnur c1iinial 1fitutore or aw workm io the eiremitner of th elonr in the one fea- lore ibat canada haa in eooaencei wiih the si tea ttialuijanereeuilry chmtcrkn n autaywijil ritxr dafierotta in pgje oroamp wa m dat- f fltry triu by hit eatrema and if f tboto any ehare could be made of hmn individually bared bit am aratoit hit eoun- try or of baein refuted 10 lift it up to defend bit 1 eotimry ajnal internal or lenal e why ahou mr- baldwin complain if more j t kloutd ahtre the fl r- jeal alatetoian tn bem trw ot of office 1 i antwer featloaly iai ihaa avuea from a eauto whieh 1 ant truly aorry todiveoeea in mr baldwlti cwieter mf m twul a want of political patriot 44 of every other manly prattiea i quality of t aialeacun doet lord john lui i bear aveh allejianee to ata 1 r that he would oarulie lib eoanlry 10 veep it in power moncanoreif pknetoir ao nl tiaktl h mr bauwiit pritale utini i ibould wiah to ny nothing or noihior offrntive but knowing ihe utttr ooarftee of all fairueaa and eneeotity amon bit more imoardiate frtrndt i am quite aware of tlie few that i ahall be n0t4 foully aaiareme i to aajr aaofioea foe evpoainx eerat hit public cha racter yj rnt of doty to the public hat how ever ihla aaauranee in otercominj nay priale feel fop on tbeoecaaion of that eiptaoaiioo that 1 kn iw ihai toek not only to ul bul 10 a loyal 1 t f 1 arjd ihtt i kfow bow oxreedinxlf few and inieniccant mr oaldnini out aod out aopportera in tpper canoda rrojy 4irrw how utile the pub je hate taufidene ifl what tj aw or do atoeo meu of uieua either rebelled aaimt or declined 1 r jfj tw govrrnutent 0 l77 1 hare come fiivw n1 1 tiofrfonk ov im t bo f 1 w 0 abomi tr btd iktiii frue niirtii itton or o pubttc or ttfmer 01 a party aaf to the honour of th former name hia cbaracitf practical 4ec not arire u mat bo aaid indeed that lw diameter ikioh1 19 brituh america in one tente tia bowettfi cannot be aaid in lh acme of hta bvlnj a fiir rcpretentaiionoflheprlneiplea aodaplrit of her mjj ir irantatlanlie auuecta but merely be caute hit pame will be recorded in hiatory ftf aarrc ocriiuat ofnn flfcifenj that aeideerlhat been neatly aa fatal to canada j a to the ou culontea ti hie opposition to the 1 btiiith principle of rentibfe goremment of ihe j former governine or mfn chyreh paiiy in all ihe 1 old and prevent nith american coloniet we foty the brillth goveramcnt nol only be- eaute it la baitiih but became it u the frteal and trceenment an raeih noionty becattte think- ic 0 ottrfathera rli died to auataio ita philanthropic principle bet bocauae we thefr aona are prepared lotfostfj tthether we unci them netily aaifcd in the ocw or betrayed by ihe judaa lit nf ihe cotonial rpumcan what t aay will i fed ke t lonfaileeileeho in iho bfat of ctrry inyal ma in in province and in 1 e a ir if nee of cvrry dilojal one my of 1 inrt antra out nf my prrlecl hvovkdpn lh in the raidca of r baofitcn rkromatbna or fftll cawada to itlioflt i wh more pariktilarly 10 appeal the former or loyaliite are at tliia day t0 ihe lalirr or rcoublicana in juat ihe mnae pro- jtoflion at in 1357 lt 0 a aoaf 10 ona man i tlk dttlnt eil haee ariata from repubttcana havinf ufccnthc taercdnamtof reform in win fl rrfofnwra nee that hi be no nafff permitted irt js dekrve thr gonffderce of ih oerior gntral ad bof majetlt govern i mem by riinrin at thia critieal period unbound i nii ki aperially to the mt nnblc of ilieae tha cm ti upper caatada rearitaclf liteugfoni in b- 1 ttrrntth to ihe prolecth of ioctery peculiar nvltiijt and real intereai 1u raluin round hi cacellrntv uo rally round r r i that ia dear in w at rtione or aonnlta for we aeeue bri- u ronneaion we aecdr reanonaiblc uorriwneril au mo nil arcuc he imdiic opening of kint coluxt in all christian uodire v u under britiah mouarehicil inalitutioaa atone hi libetty it peoiceted at one from tpanuy and 1icltnuivea fflhol riial ibrct eoultf bv beiirr h int j by otlier thm bjliah aytiant ne on bi- lih piiiple mull be wuliag tfadty to chanpa tluin fir it 1 nof th 4w m far rrwiici 0 rarefy 1 ihe brttih yieun are bul the iniromli rhecmbodymtni laat weareeiia- mnucrd af the upper canadian pm aaya sir charte mcealft mual have i heir inu real protected and thole briiuh feeliaja mh u deference ihey ore turrly eniitlrd to in 1 british colony thoeaniiituiional inalrumenl of aiuininj thcac it a moat imprlonl but yel a aeeondary conaidera- noti to the peacikat eejoymeia of the lhina lbent- cjm the milebeat meaua to tho promotion of our inlr- rra reformera may depritd it tj be found t lord syuenham had the inteeeat of the protmce at hrart and there fore reformera foueki for hit excellency 1 but mr euldwioa aymptihi eaimd ed only to 1 parr and therefore we djd nol for merly and will nol note right for hi he may rcl aaturcd in faet it ft at for the take ofh lard sydenhaui lm i in common with the coun try or iinally tried 10 think ike ey beat of mr baldwin j and regarding him at ihe rrcal apottk of reaponiible corernrnem i hate ult i taw my tr- for and found out lhat me baldwin nai aof tout rnova a ditlinttih 6fitren pury oao pum 00 jreraj couiinued to ttefrirod and defend hu edarac- leeio the hour ofln need still willing to brtkte htm if out iho highmtaded at leatl the true and diaitereied adtoeale of reipooiible gotrnmen- a principte ao dear lb my hcftfl i tried to ea lo rumttarxcein whihr ha v yftviwr pccdhibn aisdofmypnci fact fnatcrtneleat hii etident halivn- gnae him all lb jmti nlioutly could i foe i hate no ympaihy with that pteudo liberality or tonlradic- iro which makea people pray to be enabltd to fot- gite ibeir enemict the grcateat oflencet when ibey uni not forgirr their fricatda the amalleal difference of opinion to eoooere with the aercifvl citcmntent of our aauwfbpj wo aced unariifoinffy to coope rate wiih mr baldwin ii pomotinj an oblivion of the political obenca htehairienaa eontmittrd in 1837 but tine he cr to take ihim oam 10 hia boooi while they boat that ihey hare not changed we iaou uxtt be pardntd if we would relur be ea- cjted the aama honor by remawirnrj hit political ffienda epeeia1ly a we hate errry rcaaon lo fear lhat on q may boil orer tooae povlion of the prov- loce iodignaiion when one of ibeae dajt and it will be aa toon aa rv- can he advitc the eletation to the haghcat t l ji truvi of doctor rolph or aomo oihfrootat 1 h n g ei m no reaton that wo can think un1ea 1 be thai ac it nof to ntaca more guilty oa mr btdtrin aimar nowadaye it duet not tceua el all nccaiiary to mv bavin hb conacience void of of fence lowaidt cod that he ahould ovv and keep hia eonacieocc void of bfienee to- warda man nor hirine violated the greateet of ihoau 1 and offtrneied ha feilowman la an oalent hnutrtfiby hmviblhty dry matt vuu uaa mulet doca h acem at all required that be muitevcrcue a tnodrtl repentanee end not glory in hi crime- 1 would not be ujutt bul 1 cannot draw any other inference than that wiih aome people the utc rebel lion la not riowed nor trouf anotftrr htbtuha 6c pieireo in he light of a crime at all to ahow the glaring injuttice of whkh m bald win haa been gvilty and lhat hi entire effort hare been directed lo cltreu u rebel and to jnault the lyaiii we hove only 0 lake a upercia glance at hi laic conduct- llo pcrauadea ua to forgive and iry loforgrl that hi friendt united to cut mjr ihroatt in 1837 and we do ihii the mure readily becanao we 6nd il ncerary m adopt one eourie in dcaliu with ihe political ottendera of bcth i and hare therefore to grnt to ihe upper canadian re be the benefit or th palliation hehrrau did not exist but in the foreign national origin aa troll as groracr mitgovcr t4enl of lower caoad since great offence have bem pardoned iho o 1 ood all other loytit in the pruiacee roi ca rrpliny even the family compact night hare turely an oblitlmi of their cocnparatwely ii t w liiotirnccf which at but oflercra againn p and faction and nut againai ihe tawt of our country or ihe ry founda tiont of tociciy if mr itatonm ai u loytuit tvutd not oaein ihec tmalkr mallera aa at but the errora of a frwnd he ahould at leait have hod the policy if he had not the delicacy to remember that frtarritfyalir ricked them in thai light and aiaee mr c jfjivin and hia organ the ex aminrr choooe toeonituue to recall the jang pail errora of lojaliata aa their tock roiiricl ix noi 1 hey cannot jutlly complain if io amv de fence lovatiti appeal 10 their own wcapona and retuaciiate a year f the ghoitt of the r cbeltion to make mm irrmbte personally 10 an eitcnt lhat tbey wvfliu h h r-n- fares but mr uwa and hia imaaia carry ihtlr mt- litnily to far aa not 10 spire even the obvious truth from violation any more than the feeling of he lie kg or ihe memory of the dead though fcceriy alltc toibe notorioua factorarr batdniva aervilily in allowing ihe tuve 0 ptcct for he could not utterly tay of power to induce him lo remain in the veeutiv council for many monvha every day of which be felt ihe caute of f ponaroijfy to tkt copu giotly intuited in hit m r- fonv mr- baldwin and hit oon continue to via hie ihe uuih by trjing 10 gull the public into ihe beliefi not only that be l ihe brel advtelc of ihe peupkt righis ami ii tnol worthy and impariul adtiaer in dispeneur ibe natmno of the crown but thai any one it no dares lo bo indrpendcni of him and hi immediate follower is no friend of ihe people rrrmtofrhe sugar lilandt m exammtr 0 15v4 acraioer wow refrmf atk yooraavr what horrible crime tin caitittof auovrener fkicral i commu ted 1 ti reply ai uinaiiouti be lhat ilia e eelleney though he hat dona nn hi n ayaintt ihe eoumry naa put hia fool on 3fr uamvtht party and dcehiea ever atain to art in tie council wiih a man who notoriously prcfrre o ey oeeasjon ai pariyt 10 hit cnuirys tntrrrtu in tact ke head and fronl diir charlet mct- ealfea oeterdiag it that he inrj aorrrf hit tol- emn oalh of office but in fulnlmevtvf ti ubtiaiiont imialr on eonlmbin to think fr list sovereign and for her pvoiinre and i know doubt whelhtr now lhat all jsmiiopjj on prtat 0 ccrrnn rf ire at rei od not imwl clettona nen cifme lh ditemt of upper canada lei us ark our towc whether the bitin feeling of iia papultilon could have any ympaihy or even toleration for hia mawkiah liberahiy nhjch led him while att ihe while neglecting every veil known fecung 0 upper canada 10 dignify ev prejudice of loner canada ilh the name ofcvfirig ad to practice a most ruinously liberal prirtcpte in apportioning to the ihe pro- aawktl ibmll r lower fr j- 1 ihelr bindl in hand etldcnily wo but pueititely j s 10 deceuedinlo allowi y or mere private feetingt to place hee dtown to b not only incapi rerou be the cause nhat payment of ihe adminiuation of justice in since the local rcouurces uf the paeiicular of upper canaj- a principle of ernacluts if whveh no repreeentalivi of the interests canada will ctrv be found mad enough to nin of profligate wtie mr last man lu apply 1 tit own til lvliy m b ids if luegscnne ituiat eibbi 1 meant fvr the c j id win tvtnu til in 10 a tniro a ia apopet reprrentgtir the difference belwrn ilv irr general and those of mr dahlt ecllticy viea any ify bi j purpose f povrrnmj wiie m prac lie ally derrerje orcr meant or reward for th nuepo f pari the rformert uf upprr cja wilt however arre with ere lhat 5rr charl- mdcalfs m ihe enlish and mr baldwin th american way of il that bowl reformer thoti parkr too fnosr the surveyor general had ihe rath of mr bald win and ihe radtivt rf jour povl vut on led head m 1841 for dorin uljr tr and tliek by lord sydenham vrrojai he hid pledged himaelf to iji conttiluenlt n ttp ftevpoaatble coveromet jirorriaiy 1 tnv prorhct et ihe rform have actualy rvrcited a gre jiis oro- himteif may sut people at a ditlanee- ean c conrrrre u fvawshe tha mr baldvint personal poiutarity cou oc to overrated at il ha been though partua here con underaiand il when ihry remembo the great eiertoa ntada by the omjaer newspaper to vrtlt vp hia then p oualiiea ofamal iho tried or posuiva poliikal rce of jnhn by dime per- roiaion peaident of the eaecouse cuuneil former j lhc lkt n had tfc beceli of wr hnev cate and vthieh sjn caldwia would be tv intrrcat fwarrilawamrbilli rlthough the laic cxecsitirc mat jetuitkatl pretended ihal thia wa a measure 0ierr imooiiit- no ta but inerrlf enabling ihe tiuwtcis to isa thcmselte fur their local improvement grateful to mon morin lor thai grcm feat of mornl courage his introducing into his schocl bill out upper canadian pffcmafl t local aasetsment m mi r httherto unknown m lowrr canada iho country j purpovct nnd appeared lo care tittle or netting frr would have been contented to wait l4l the reprcaen j the iutercsta of the country btfen to doubt their laiitea of public opinion in lower canada indiea- true title to represent il in the eiceulirc and his lid that a farther atp in whal iby and he know excellency aoon became aware they pcfaonally 10 be ihe riaj rood would be popular in lower never bad the cooftdenee ur tuppoel of ihe upper canada bul till such time it would have beet eon canadians ttfi aa lntrrumenft lo ktop in ehcea the other eiueme pany in the oorhklof upaer tmf hcatlwcsnr a afid inoi vi r i axo or nrvotio to tiir ccik or tfia coon- tay ih reibrxrc to tilt inuputi or a a att the eaiglith nhk have of cmrm had urd sinr laya oratory and hs name to dsail- then bn sr robert peel fc hi lfvdthip at ncll a e aovr mr bejdwioiand tru 1 m r be use mo derate ma 1 inrst ia w ypstalpiltq colohial dcitv ih pawaaaa eel hu lurdtliip is t- bvfore ihe publie a 4 lillsaiin rtt i- tn llkc mr ajwir emlii bawwiiiahaa hot ct brt gs aad deplored by hit nodical fkndt j l uf hmekv great taleni b xrst wvo nada ha erx a pt utre o dj7 omeao pa as i jii ihe puvtic person la centered nearly the whele ioduenee of that peeeumpiuoui faction which but ycslerdav on the false prrtcnec cf reprrachling upper cansda mon opoltsrdalhheponerandpaironaseoflhc provutr till interfered wiih oy s- chatlea metcalfe whi seein lhat ihey were constantly occupied with ptty loedtaslike mr dildivu was 41 arikiikbrtaat rtpudtaled lu r of in wrs ioraehlp ia an honeee manihan xjejlj taaujabv dona ul e o rriai d a very fair al by no 11 niid t in getting troduktd info eif th province tevirnunce ihrouib this oittcmana bein in an oth ef tmail even thouh not in the cabinet thai h have ejoted through ihe mure noity and ks rwe jd pfaelictl rtrormera the lale eaeeuuvv ihjah they bad so much more in their pnwrr if indrpendrnl mrmbera o slae aaemhly at lhat crialt amon hom i had ih hanor to hi aated mr parks or ihe provincv bet mvrst mccuvie of rforn by rcatlcav ptitaic phl pai- ka cowtittexcv theeleewt fjr middlesct irpnuxh- tnt attfmr txu aw 4 rf v oojrcrs which mr ilineka ed uf y jgj to crtrcl i ajamj ihe doeuuiem inf j apeak for itadf in iu lot of name may be f nucleus fr what the etcmiatt ofy- l as a moderate parly thougs trf means an indication ofow arms if nf had eireunaaunees permmed voum p to have ioinrd in this declaration o enee at br- batdwin if mr hincka wa then trulv ho- dmoun- rinj mr parir 1u own aonei wre w have becriihr ajuree of nosmlanrrj to mr hioeba when he hitnlf wiihin f hl ihereafte paid whit i allow u be a jm tribute lo lord sydenhams adnrntlraton i mr harrison awd doicrtwg the ioipuctteau mr baldwin i it h mo of those realtor hkh p r aa aurrassiag imanlionj that mr ualdwm ahsuld have the rltronury now l wow up mr hineba and mr baldnin to tu pirff powj of poliliroj oarfection svhen we re h v the time of irfr otienaun of their denounevd mr hmrbt a oatn od- principle ardmr hmcaavfho had the prcol mn hard or nannted mr baldwin at a man oc m whc vanity to tare him frum aujrwal insiinifi- cance had sold mm and upper canada to ihe low ercanadians we do not require to plead ofal ibem ihjirj fsolubut and dtmved want ofihe efidcncu of up 1 r canada we need orly appeal smf euallf real and nearly a naloriau wam contnleocc in thcmulvct to the hfrormlrs of tin mlddlfkx iountvnp tood his owo ptrmnaj inftticni he rmioi sn ljs eiuiaiionas a mtf fy mnn neoid doin- ewkcwvt actth which i fear would eventuate in revolution mr bautviu bimsrlf agree stistl mr to ilinbiri that the more imndialc re of th late rrbcllton it least ila chief hone of turret- wa that ihe nooulstion had been alienated from ilw jrrirrent arf win- helped upon 1 lie rairean od higoled llih chutb faction lhouh ihe m- bc r nl nnl drd nol ao of but wtrc mnal hffi it oapated to ibe prestimpiion oflbc church of eng land the mas of ihe aeple indrrd did not hn i- cttlwr- ouaclva axt n ktttexta itl doth i 1- akd tx the myohjrciion to mr baldwib ia lhat however coiostv and it antras eilfcvtfrx ihjt if wo continue to rupport mr batdwrn as our reprearntaiire in ihe covemmrnt sre cannot eo-niiiii- if the loyally of upper canada remains a mailer ofdi pute now tou will bear me out j aavin hat it irat nof a juuvafaa pary but a rofrftrverynmira fax- hon that its 137 bared it aot ojaintl the briiiah ccvcrnbaent at a dirrcl proof lhat mr batdnina connection and influrnec a wiih the faction and not with iho pjriy i would aleo conndenmy appeal lo she pc- rience ot nil loyal reformera vhciberlhry could help feeling ihatl they indiidully had not me mm rff eprrtcnfofio in or ijtvict with ihe ue ec nsiderin tl ven far fo auflicuf 1 mi6vii n csitivc and fhai in tact aa contiituted it waa just tvorenhingthcl-waofcandmanandaimhin- cbtlmeiion to l heir claim oa hi eiecllenc yfonndaiinnttaocirtc inal aam bod ua illcausuj dircetli 1tci1 waa ivmced in ihe u sloriea of its fabric in at vajrtkajar roiony but the itwrfwiraajsf ijtfarcanidasatroly loyal will aturedty ivbel aaiot ihe britith covernmnt jf tt utter mr lilaan to weaken the very foundation 0 colonial aociely by buildinj it on o roundwork afnmotat- ir loyaltr tk coloniata tnd- iskcoollt r 3ito avfrtntv this to aajaa is indeed fsiactlcattv vtuu ij upinat the jrit oovernmenl and againtl bnun lct ocaaaure the people of ftt provir ihol il at at this moment doing us ihe mol incoltuublc in juryin eugtaod tit ivinc suppd lhat in mr bawwin a man nf awavfwl loyalty our aeniimenis have a fair ttprtuziation inenrlasd i wamppcaled lo on thit tulrct tr aataofaij thsdea of polilka fro lh t lo cbartiat all were staggered at tha apparent aassary and wouhl not be satisfied i 10w ihrm al mr bamarinaesevation waa eauwdby ihe col- saaiiu hatred of the high church faction hut in uatlru eoaild not discover cause uflicinl rot a inry rtprcjted pt mlowint a loyol province to be aw4 by a disloyal faction 0 mbytcl biuvrin patt character lhe qurtlion was apam ad ip eeji 10 me in england did h wet rtfr pr1ftokutnnlru pt the lale rebellion decd- g to orht against tru fnrmcr or to tsjn oui m octacr orthe ullrr f remembtf ell the feeling ftark of one genttamtn of ihe most liberal writm loilue and whose boaom unit as high anv avian s wttueauaeorfrerdommrwrpoor mr iwvowttt m bt a amjjrfvj oy s 11 not a jrtfoa and havo nnt lh real body or iho reformera felt that mr baldwin rrwrvcdall ui runncknee favour and patronage for men of doubtful loyalty to ihe reatrt extent be eoo1d without 1 r more than would be rood policy it fieai the britiah prejudice aa they term ihe loy eltv of upper conads on train pointj however as no etery other tneao friendt of the people mr baldwin and haa parir make ihe moal barefaced mureprrsentatioca to the people and ihry go 00 for at to inatal on a fomer contrary 10 ih eoosciic oa and memory thai tt was fa mr eawwin per inallv that they fovghl and triumphed in iho up per canada eseciiooa of iwi here again and without uuhinf to depreciate the uanitanec of mr baldwin t hia frwiids i oppeal with eooftdcaco in ine front body of the roformirra ioocat mo out in totally denying thiv bold aaseruoo ttwea for lhat greaimt frtend of upper canad lor j sydaoham and for bcaponswc govrrawcrii that the reformer then fouxm the family compact and em church tori of the j lord sydrnbma obieel m it is uil th uwlfr er flftiir paovik c polilically to rtf isvj and branch uon imcontrrr ha alwya boon and u ks amtoerof5lhdeecmbr mr abeet brcaawa iho ikat or k2salmws ihey m ru eiiiercis unpopul mr bildwla and hi fa- oogh about the partifuiar tnjs r enough aooui sne 7 of tu compact to the public to perpcioau th da lopularfaettoaa th poilir1 tort in trade of tlm to be capable o tolheytopu it is held up 1 a ihe beat prroaraiicn that n mm ahouldrr liy avidc all reepeet for himseir at v ahall ace mr baldwin hat donrlliruugh criminal deration to par ty il it not al all to iho point hat il bo otgucd in fa rorof mr datdwu ihit he piraonafy has tn am rircumafaarrs no nerd to covrt llie aweeu of of fice for if 4e ia not ntfnfvy hc ssme ccuj not 1 believe be said of the must of hit to league t and nt any rale ii iacvideut lhat ihe tndepe of hss puraehadnot eommunicated itself to hia mind aa haa wn evinced by his senility to sir chirks mticalfe 1 i do not however at preent ditcutv m bald wiiia uriroe character or my private freuut would o course lead mo to read him the greatest possi ble indulgence mr j himself be it remarked late ev ery occasion- to ittslit publicly on his bejo conaid- eeed a araono fiarr haw and therefore fairly reaponaible fa ihe principles and tela of mia paiatv arrr it oaoak till he ehonaea to repudi ate thcni whatcwrwj under a frcung of con eioua inability mihi feel inclined lo do his parly it it quite evident irtj not rat contented wih what ihey coll mr batdwjvs principle bving in op oration in the government he mutt be ut ihe e ecu lire boditr or rttct and the influence of their utira if not republican viewa cannot bo got fortcd back into ihe councils of the colony to that while prtttndinr to fi hi for mr baldwin personally and hia character the etxonisvrr is in fsd ghiin fur the wbolc urearniable rmbodymcnl ihe beginning ai d ihe ending of jf influence and character of ihe rvaaealfacuonofltopcr canada foe in m bsld ccnlrce all tu mfluccco and ehtrscier and in mr hincfcs begins end ends all itt practical latent let ua ihea in the asrvl place i a ac a amilc of bow the late eiecutive ireat their late feiend ihe adraeatr of rrsponaibtc imruent see era- tarrofl3th dccsnibrr ryonrer sat 0 km took out harriatin haa aold himaelf end ia irtiiig to buy you acni him back emnif rturn an aon ttt roformrr or return an ftofffsf issys ps n t jli rejected mongrel lell wm to c bark lo bis matter pot hnj nold in hia rack and tend that barb too your vutea mutt bo uurdnted by anoih er price it will be clear lo the public that mr harrieoue lanonrtt in mr baldwin pure siht h jttsl that be atould are lo part eompany with mf batdin ctco although mr h in 1 1 1 links siecvtrlri mel ealfc rim and mr baldwin wrong i sir coartea melealfo too haa uen sfjtfoanf enough to loso confidence in mr baldwin and fie nomtnt hacclleney dam in da nit ha at once deaeanda not indeed in their mindr but la rrikin aioottia from beinj the ablrst nsn with oui eiceplion that ever held ihe tfoaiiniee of cna- to bo m a maai who haa studied the genius of britiah conatriijtioo and imbibed hr noliooeof hbevtiea and rtthl ofa free people inoo- ihe palanquin bearors nf the kit or ihr weay hraded ckvrltmiv we have ihi dai rj p andsrtoriuaicnl sn lw colutnm of th eamir a lelttr addressed to jou by ivjirfis l ea the pioprjeiae of llial uurral and a mniber or ihe llolhc ofassembly recommending luftot 0 coun ti nance mr l tsuuld rnv ai npal io yu for mtr mafjraies and merlin- thai had deserted his party p tjes that actus fef ait mieruare f re viesrt 0 0 eorruov firernien r v af 6e renf oocfr to parttamtat the roinrusrcs in or motinwiou in sis pulilicity io aaatam of t serinus iavj t ktraordinary a nature mr hinckt my navr been actuated by the moal pure oru paln fetin2t and il would not bceome ut to call s uction hit tar plea- ccra m ilrvea but fihiaen we le uro l wto inoa tulwauaj m aibr may have 0l ihc20u0 viunioii of mr ltwbe nwcnce innlm temuins unshaken we hate ion ko- him and in and out of 1aruamem i ec found him the firm and unbending tcate of irc righla and libcrlica of ihe pepu- dmj the dark cal period of thi counttia hiaiey yo ari uneomproniiviog and atihful frie retfenl oecation you gave unduubtrd e f estmaliofl in whieh you bojd hit character service will you abandon uxb a nan at the per aumntuoiit rfronimrndaltun of an indu eannat bclatve that 0u will mr pr hour what he ha aln aya hcenan ho aialcnl keforerer lhoj has been orbsa par abandonfnrni of prmriptr and we feel- tc rent bctjy of rtormcrs haikd arfal anpriinteri tooffir- utd r h amwpafc a it itjera li bad in him and on a c oft and hit the prr- j we d eon no cured that wlight hit tint which to itvutc uf qorsiicn of rcof cov- f ie whieh no mm in canada iuuly ably ai unceovingly ti his this ijv cwiiii ttrmbt ihe via satatpwav q irtie ei1 miee if than mr pjrke a sense ufjuatice to nit upright ufrlligmi deanrvinj man mutt bo received by you at our apo logy kr thus obtruding ouraelvea on your notice and we fondly cntemin iho hopr thai by an over eon sidcrd 1st more than toualjtutirt ta upper canada 10 insist n the r xpeftte or the admiuiflratinn of jus lice in ihia aeclion of ihe province and eveiy other hem uhveh a waul of the principle of local assess- meat in iwrr canada made a dlrectehasge on the provincial treasury ought also 10 have ber foyers ujt lac jhttrku of upper cunoitu ad yaidfro the tame am4 sourer and by mr baldwins not doing to it papulaliori or upper canada had lhr most vital iitcctts most garingy safrjjlerd bj htm l4 ut now 1 r iie more iaamediale cause of tle withdrawal from mr baldwin of the confidence atl support of the moderate party let it not be forgotten ihit they were in the first 7 tpvrntd aa modhftsth tlsroggh hie medium of hij own or ton te ezamfar they leave him o brcmic ac i but otrauit a n nol live true friend of res- rojafftta ivvrnment beautr in fotulsf nnd lhat irwut hi rsrtd tnc rlcuf aw ta srwi mttji ufr alamed cause incapahle of the praclice of responai- we covernrnenl tint ihry cannot conceive to ante wholly from mere iftaoirift and tbey arc there- fere left to conclude lhat sf not in hi mind at least in the minds ofihote who eoniiitote ait orrsiurc frw iriauuf there ia an jrrior object bch ukes preccdrucf of ihe principle of reionsibi1iiy 10 the people under afommmvo insftfufion the loyal reformera in forming this opinion do nol judge merely from the evideflt vrtib of mr baldwin and his extreme supporters to perpetuaie in ihe eon linuid ciitence oft be family oe high cbtjrcb com pact n corruption of nhiehthey a a party may continue to be aa they hare olwaja been ihe mag- lots or evidences to the canadian public and with whkh by keeping ur en endsrat and moat oinstve irritation ihey nay disgust the british pyu c lo in eatent which will result in the rcpublrtana hearts aviah 1 the discarding of canada by england al together i tbey appeal lo he inecnirovertible fact lhil for many mouth mr baldwin haa been iho ir responsible minitter of sir charles mcieallea will while he has all h while had the duplicity to pre tend to hc pubtk thai he cnnlioued 10 be the re- apontiliu minister of ihe ipmolo aa tnfranchmtd or doing aa he has done mr eownin jj been tt froior 10 what he afreet wiia us to be fiucawd ut rcipontibjiiijr 10 ihe aonist mo haa done all thai he could to ovcrthvr our conatit uiin- al rights and privifefrrt which ihe operation of ftc- aontible government if not a delusion ought to be ihe acknowledged irgiiimic meant of securing nol only lo mtraelve but of handing down unimpaired 10 our poalcrity aa ilieir moal valuable and valued birthright the chartered embodiment in fad of alt our rrghta and liberties at colonist find ii no more ihan fitrto ailmitthat sir cstf jrincorijb itrumrliuiuni ijti iviu trnrn hit exertfrnrjt sres pre pared ho longer to rantvtt him on rrrry matter this naturrdly aa the corstltlulional cuurerj woud nuiurally hare been the course which a statesman of iho tried and unirersally aeknolrdged lalrnl and it of ihe present oovernor cnrral would ha adopted utt drr ihe eircumstarcsv hid hb eterlteocy taker the proper tiew of it- ilia rfeellencya recent arrival amontt uv ought t however lo be cotisijercd and lfro rathlt condfintiieig ihr governor general in thia particular intircr the fact wilt b borne io mind that his kcltcncy mutt havr fell thai as a ccfttitutioial fiovcnmr he must ovpctid for hit ability to chance hia adviser on the ruppiirt of pub ik opinion which ai ihe lime be found t in ei haul ion from the iffect of a ion eourtr of wreteh- ed poliikal ckcilrmvht in llae prorincr public opin uv hid in fici under sir chtrlra bsgol piten no indication but that it was the play thing uf fiction sir charter mrlcalfc found that ho could onlr triumph by tclling th bnirith mo or rustic cniox yet gradually awafco to the vm htnds thst rn id him and earn if we allow hi there i yet toencthinr to be aaidtrgainit sir chaelet eoufac n ofarr and fc extraordinary cieeumtlaneru of the province ihre is much in is present eircumalancev 10 say in defence of his witdom if it were necest farther 10 defend w chtrlcs metcalfe we miht remark how good hit kxeel- irneys right was o suppose that mr oaldwiit thould know so much belter than hia eieelkncy a ttraner had he vrtnt of knoning what the peo ple he reprccnied in the council of the colony ca- prclrd of lum tit thai he ahould elire the moment ihe governor general th wid a want of eunfidrncr in him pcrsonatlr by denying him the iwiiileeeof canada tmt rattlt cobtpactj thia high i eh factions rxcluiivenets and in tolerance we in fact the origin and its exihance formv ihe my tenure of the lile popular influence mr bilir 1 has enjoyed i opposed the tnro- duction of retpontible gaernsenl ino ihe colony and till lttairsffonoprfaftpfr wasacl at rest hie populatrun hid nolhin for il bui 10 tupport it ad- vocalr mr baldwin however little confidence ihey had in him otherwise i hare ntcr ibrcfoie view ed the decition of public opinion in favour of him as much more ihn an indieaiion of the compact greater unpopi i iriiy the in floe nee ofihi llih cwreh faction on tfie province haa been mol bliyhting liaoppoettun to every thing poputr forcing the people into ihe arms of ueh men at me t r and hi friend naa arsaajajf of im tu- aiatlll wm f poliikal i vents n ihe colony apeak loudly of ihe raismsnagemeni ofiu rducatwal funds and showt how injuriously on ibe encouragement of our colon ial youth the old system has operated which made the narrov done of church ture amj the only road to pcasibic prefcfmenl in profeatinal life it term to me lo spesk well for ifie vinoe ortbe counlry that iu youth ahould have preferred the humbler wafts of induiiry lo educating theinselrea for publk life with such voul degradation allachcd to ila prospects of advance nent undr retpomibtc govcrnmtnl however the face of kings will soon change for the belter kings college mil immediately be opened lo all christian bodies in the province and the gradual extirpation of religious bigotry and high church tocjitm will ihen have commenced to aecurethe nw college bill the reformers ahould plejge their repeeatntaiivg to cooperate with sir charles metcalfe and ace lhat il be made the very 5 act of the hvst scatson of parliament 1 would rather are a duiolttli mi of the urriott trjfh fwcr canada which would hot now that ire have retpontiho government be to grvat an evil aa it nould before hive been thao allow the lower ca nadian member to defeat u ti aamo say tbey wil1 in luxratiying ihe coge thit dolony cannot be retsinrd an append if of the britith government irthakisu1ling pretcnaioui orthe church of england are tiot put a period to by opening the college to ill- these protenana led mainly lej the revolt of the nld colonks and if not put a ttop 10 here they still prove aa fatal to the connection at the republican p incites or praelkc of ihe otw extreme faclion icttbc province ric ia ita mixht and by givint a generous support to the gtisernor general enable mm to extirpate thee two factiont which are and jit ln ic i 1 p 1 j i- nillpprevjur source of arcaknrti ta upper cinad keeping it a scene or continued excitement political bauff- 6ctd far party ttrngtles in winch the peopl lose kmsecreiary fr the c a the addiiionol r p t tonirm ibatt ilia lnrdh is nt made ny mere thm mr baldwin 1 i whel youi i nil itckti to serve itig ma jam y parliament wrare gcntfcmen tour moil imw 5rrvantt davin tonarnx m p mtieolm caiehojm elmi sttctr m p i jons roaitv ml p p gcohoc isoasvktt ml ckvc m pp j w pottrtm mp laae dvchsv m jomx cook mi p p java moonm p p n tiittuffov m p r joh gii m p p j william h p p haastanvasmltlt h p p p mcuoktto m i p inlon i8lh june 18h i nould nov tlntf- to mr dtldwins neglect of ihcinirrttt and ficliira of voce r canada in ihr unjust lecautr unequal ptmctpu or tin aaataimeul bill a irrll as in the want of all prtneiple i had tmoal aaid of deerncy a hia perintiinf uiht after main in pailiamenithc aciaof thai friend of lpprr canada lmd ssdniham to fc traduced and mia lordship ffltrj tljnd bniiik inw ufa wj v c1 fw nalue th a ikeih 1 ptare enable mr of art f wr brwif li pnr fa mi nalue th aaje 1 laer n4ajt y nraue iho ltcl- ptiri nau rn mint robril msm i i reai fdhi yires then aetia 19 taiify at how ta baldiria eat off ten to parage jua1i rtsastlfe or by askin- advice and nol mowing il ilia etcrltency c ihat ihe honor of the crown and the inttres nftlv people rcmiircd that he should pronounce a diffpreul d ciiioci from that whieh mr baldwin had rreommended mr bald win ouht not for a j 4 o have given the coun ctl the aanetion nf his name ofer ho waa aware thai there were acu peiformcd hy ihe ooternmcnl m ihe colony to nhjeh he wa not privy ft la no palliation to the crime of a srm who tasrtn vrox nnnrir tiif arrosinjlltv or ritf hiciictt colonial tacit lhat bo ha been onlr a tool in awrr hands this eaeuac u juti ha wc might anlieipatebcm made for him wlwn crtcroirhmcnlt by republiean- itm nn ihe constitution of 1 he colony ramr lobe found out as ihey assuredly woold were the go- rcrnnvnl aiin rntruated 10 hindt so weak even mr baldwin wannest private ftrnds do nol approve of hit political rourse and conduct and when ihey difend hifn ihry forget iheie higher duty to ttremahvra to reform nod to their counlr thryennonly defend us atottvta byaton amsa blc partiality at the rxpense of his judgment and his intellect mr ftatdwin nrirr can tatttfactorily accoubt to the public for hit infatuation but unfortunately itt prejudicial ratcda on our ubertsca and intrretta will long onltive ih femporry nucttron of whether itt cauto wa to bn found lo his own isllrmiiy cf nurooae or in the malignity of his parly the reformer of upper canada muat br now atinedof what they have long reared that mr baldwin is not a safe man 10 be in the ovcrimcnt of any british rotnrty tnu i the inevitable con- ctuiion they muu arrive at whether ihrt regard mr baldwin own court of conduct and want of all management in ihe pari or scrutinise ihe character a of ihoso who influence him which we will and with few raeepiion riircm or republican and con aeteilioutly o no ejovbl j reiormera rc the parties chiefly deceived in mr hi i 1 a hvivif trusted htm moat and oa the most sirrnly iiprrght guardians of ihe public liberties md intercut cf cff canada they will kt the batite terminate either wayj for 1 fie great body or the elect ore never h my influence wiih cither eilrcmo faction beyond the election vrechl 1a 11 n 1 m i 1 in moi striking cnniratl to ur baldwsna char aeter wc ace in ihe character of our prcmnt uaver nor general ihe kial rfuatineations at vicing for supremacy the most practieal lalruir the most en- larxed and liltcral nrineipls and ihe greatest t rieiice ad minnn aitd hit lveellanat admin itiraiion haa thia othor inoi imporlaat advantai ihal hi charaeur it most imputtttf trutted at head quattek indeed men cf all tlmdev ofopiniun and poliilra eoncurrcd on sir chalet metealfto ap- potntment in heaping praises on sic robert peel not lore stanley at taatsanl giten ihe canadun ovrmmert to a jtctdd ioro in preference to one of hit own political phv becaute sir chirlc was considered by a thefltutt man in avaiafiaf for ihe slate of ihmgt in can da in sir chtrlra metcalfe t hods the forpecit f the colony would ihercfore cm ace bright did c not know ihti the tutorar cubic lord stan ley is slill at the culonial oftir but ic tared n i be much aurprtcl if sir robert pert intitting nu rr tponvibililr to csnidln publjr opni n being ositc fisrd 10 the fullest eateni oe mid the ejur foe the retire i from office of lhas last hope of our pro- vincial mih church faction although thr chief ob ject of lrd stanley goin 0ii of the ministry wilt br to allow of hie rrratly to be detired libeel act- llemrni nf ri1 rnraners 4 belirvn tt ia llie acer- i y mbit teal b lief onhia colour thai lord sianky it of all public mm whag or tory the slate sm in of the anxrlktl judmrnt and temper and trealeal prrtence on colonial subjects eatepl lord brouh am indeed to call lod stonier a yoifician were very nrahy as gera an rrerii of courfesy oa to pay the earn unmerited compliment 10 nur friend mr balduin for fibouih at a mailer of ability it kef cour0 carnpartu great thina ih irnall ihe pub lic chdractcn of ac iwtj have manr pvtiu of aim- la my both actually practice the true spirit of republicanism carrying out their theories only imlrad of carrying out the great national i r ii nhoie nellretlncd eaistenee havo jivea perhaps aa mncbw thrir nrrmaneni eharaeter lo the criiiah thcorier or pnretiplrs in which ihr orijiioatctl aa tit nominal cause the monarchr while by mrikingtytc oanat etenl mattcrtof faet a contra dil in guithed from ike mat tut of a- pinion of the american government allow atsoof their gradual change lovuil th- changing circum- aijnres or increased etilithtcnmenl ofa counlry and prevent the rreatrr evil oftho vrh inirrest of a country corning lo rebel aaai iia principles as will occur in amrricaat wll aa preventing in the character of ifte people the slippery net a of iho american chaactcr golavaih a neemani man war j a leeilabii twiic1 if aiyoner and thia hot been rrirsced to glaringly in mr p1i1j- tvino career that it aeema a if his rescue from the waves oftbe rebellion ore permitted ihotbyfou lowing u nothing daunted atnencan instead ef itfiiish beincipler ho ahotild byndbj commit political otlicipt and be fute as a warning lo ihe people nf the province lo nroid repuwicaniam they briii made to ace in him uiat error which tnev ml phi hae with dilticuhy coma 10 feel in them sieves p7oa mn balnwina loetrj cqiirotal paac tier haa t lketattll ikokatji toath itfto u rtst nroti r ion against m alurtva tdoac than erauivoc il mlnclpl 1 v hu oaavilc coxrtct it sift txfrctvr coqxctl fcfa3 pamartralt lilt- aniotx rnnnaaioky at tber or not it ia any trot ajct to preserve tl a con n a ion between canjdi snl the mother counlrj but i return l sir charles metealr 1 have ltiedetd i ho avrccsefullyiioeiuntrractibegrii erol impetasioei that via circlleneys grrat dilfi cully wdlvc lord stanley trlbnow that thu iciaaat policy is r a wed to be ibedtetilion or hia lorjjahrp ihe sssuvl irtrfy it is 10 get a fatr i ta pejuderilcondrralion fraoa the cololsia ienmediaely on hia eacclcneya arrival in cana- da sir chartea mrtcafr- with a quiet and honcat cirneainess turned lo ihe vital wbseel of the anom alous positson ofour clo polilics1be deep pm- nirution and iniuilie energy of his mighty inieltcct i jia eachlrncy neither spoultd magmtoquener like sir tranci hood had nor pubtietv rcarej nny principle like m baldwia only la knock them down again fur the amuarmcol of the puow lib li v rr- 1 whole ime and attention he ftl in rommon vasirt loed sydenham belonged to bit eouu- 1ra practical object not to any part drfusnau and lo elevate upper canada he found he muat rruih the atiii- british paiitm that to long had cart ed il wiih admirable deseti and buuoeio hi eieelleney eontciut of tnvir toflt and want of true pairloiism determined io brrns wa the usur- pinj factions lo the ur of public piotut his fix eethnrv delervnieed 10 hae powivly a 1 to upper cttadn thai tba aiwisa fm suauav o hit dminiatraiin weud tie to gel retnonaihle io seiuncnl into fuhpraclical iiprraiioo in both pro vinccs apd sir chorlc metcalfe now demaada the cooerratron in ikis truly rinh ojec uf all men v ho are uuly britil at hcael the process of his eierllenevt mmtat rmem 1 can auppoae to be tomelhin like the mlowing how io it that such mm as lord sydenham and ihe honourable wiluam moriia rhould hae in ap parent contradict n of those trineiple of frctdsm in which ihelr character ortgioalcd and for which their lirct have been aodiiur people viith an unnillmianj 1rrmbln hand ihut eupofuiav thi ptnelple of ritpo- tibiltty of he colonial 1 j r to colonial public opentcn nheh fney knew to ut the colonists courtotineial brth- riym aa briluh subjecta t the reason b plam aod tbrlout though ibay knew that ihr loiter canidlio are mojuorchieal le v had reason from the rebellion to doubt uheib er the britbh government had nol crtmwwy lectcd the means of tnabo brihth aaws lhuh the v knew tai ihe upper cansnaana oc tru ir britith in fteaawj ihef saw the ditticulty of gsrt- trglmt twmbjktt cu in the efetice oj i wei canada tt all evenia 1 ill ihe lowrr canadians ctutd bo got to act on their dtnoarchlcl feeling and attend lothefr cue aa4ttr h and at ckristians by ditriiing from their minda the idle par of emintl 7v by selling coutlnerd fa mr vsger and hi friends already that thougti it miht have ben ihe interest and lowborn glory ofa canadian fartioo or oligarchy lo opprrs ihem and ttimaiite their oriin in former timet ism biitiah government could have had no inteaujat in degrading ihe condition or vrounding use feelings of her own colonisla t ilovsjdvtilmam of puhjie anrn impelled by uo umiorfht r ialet sutpieiora imprrttrd on the contrary bf the deep eat regrets most hate eoncluded tlvit there was not before thtir minds sufficiml evidence that to luner canada ihe rebellion waa onlv nn the surface and fas ihey fundly hoprd it had nm pervaded ibe nh ta atrueiure ofils sueuty they saw ikal upper ca nada wit indeed brniah bit ihen i7 dmsiov leg wtdilk under currrsu of upper canadian poliiica ihcf saw that lo jut r of crittth cj n could nol jet b- maije ih- one nu winch the fiert ilreiions unrtrr the ijnion woum turn they ww ihtt ih am poliet if not pein ciptica of sir allan macnab ad h mm crrurch faciiun would a fartnerly lead ihem to prefer ibe inlercti of thrtr cho eh lo ihe mterctl of ihrie cocu try aul ferine take nf ihe former 10 eonti lobe the curie nflhelaller bv contniuing la deny ik real briiitlt and cunciiluiioual prtneiple calkd sua tpontible 0ernra the qoetrion thereforc al ibefieateleeion of iho union mutt unfortunately continue to be the nmn raciling one whieh under one name or anther had always on every fonct ecationben th nuctljon at the huiina in cpper canada responsi bility to thr colnuia nrd this ruinoul perpetua linn of gurtfroiri of principle of zeeeititnt must iitrvddre mioj men into the ataemb4r beeaoae ilia frierds of this abstrrl principle tile mr baldwin ntio hate not dirttnruiahed ihemearlrea j friend of ihe conacelion or of the british covmaent tid nould lose their elecuoni nhrn conncctuveonsca to he the simple qutttion al the hutjire aindvr the fvtl praetieat operation of retpontibititf in the rv- reriment acoietce4 in alto oy the loaota people uot cireptitg ihe itigh church mmmi llts eirelftncy aao saw what lord stdnhaas and mr morrtsmuu hu- aten clearly ibit aa ihe lower canadian rcprrscntatirrt uould lv t beat a comnaraiivcty rompacj oorfv nbio the upper co nadisn members wc have 00 oarncrs 0 patroov the result would b tkit trench inbueuce wculd characterise the caociu ofllic euonj tlie chief danger oflsuwa not iho inembecaof execution council being mostly or r- p f csnaduas if u were art knotcn that tat oajeett cf lever canada arc britith abjciti tnc natural jctjioaaaf of the mere local interest- of upprr canada vro mght hare auppreased and comnlaiaf i neity our local intrrcau camo lo be invadrd but our briiiah apiril mutt at once take feral the supposition lhat upper cmu nould yield herciivaactca ai a inttith cocomt asor aa iheproeclion of the local intarrals or lower canada were concerned there a ato irsan to admlnilcr thmuh other than lheiueai repreaen- talivet tnat could bn found of lite true fiehna and opiitiont of the lawei cenediana bul ihrra would bo the treatett t to iheso i 1 r canadian councillors sf ihemir brilssh ihev ahould be dithonrat enouzh toinaut on having oa upper canadian cullea m n of doubt ful or republican lenuvncier if on the attna title aa thec thmoeelvra the lorrcr canatfian couneillorv rrrldoflsr- there befog a 1 rue rpeeesion of lower canada theac upper canada republitana were known not 10 be a leua eiraeeuaion of the prioeiplca or feeline or inlereata of upper canada il nti foreaeen that this unforfunata afatn of mailer mighiaeeus iho connciuora riusas favtcrcoaida b qrjite yualiraabla in tsjing mr baldwin at iheir c lir eve from its bring made to appear that ihe majority from upper csnvj ua parliament approtrof him white the feet as lhat the upper canadian maority have w ii u thown their total draapjirorai of mr batdee in con duct and have rallied nol for him peraoraairr but rwf4 aim for tlie principle or reaponsible garer- when in dispute the liberal member fmm upper canada know ml welt iha norv ihtt rwfmnble oovrrensenl io